Git Notes idea.

Hi All,

I was thinking about possible ideas for my little pet project and I had and idea for way to tack on notes to a commit, or any object really. I know that the idea has been flying around for a long time but there has never been any implementation or a concept that people liked enough to use (unless I have missed something).

Here is my idea.

.git/refs/notes contains a tree-id (assuming that using a tree-id will not cause any problems, otherwise a commit object can be used. it does not *need* a history, but it *could* have one).

That tree has a structure similar to the layout of .git/objects, where it is 2 letter subdirectories for the notes objects.

Given a git object (commit, tree, blob, tag), use its sha as the
path/filename in this tree.
    If I have a commit 1234567890123456789012345678901234567890 then
the notes tree will have a file
12/34567890123456789012345678901234567890

That file has a list of sha1s (one per line). These shas are object IDs for blobs that have the notes or whatever that you want attached to the item.

I think you get the idea. When looking up an item, it should be fairly easy to have the notes tree and subtrees available for doing lookups. And as far as I know stuff under .git/refs can be pushed/pulled even if its not under heads or remotes or tags using already existing machinery. I am not sure, but I think that would satisfy gc operations as well. Also, these trees and blobs never have to be put in the working directory.

Does this sound like something that is workable? I thought it might appeal since it uses only features that are already present.

This could be extended so that you have different sets of notes under .git/refs/notes/<my note set> or whatever. So that you can have some notes you keep private and some that you publish or whatever.

OK, hopefully this isn't a off the wall, thats-what-you-get-for-being-up-at-2-AM idea.

Thanks, Govind.