Taylor Blau posted notes from this year's Contributor's Summit so that people who could not attend can follow along and continue the discussion on the list. Topics included the security process, Git 3.0, documentation, Outreachy sponsorship, pluggable ODB, an AI contribution policy and protocol v2 for pushes. This report covers the day's replies about who should be allowed to vote.

Justin Tobler said the proposed eligibility requirements seem too low. He argued that voters should ideally have both a vested and a current interest in the project, and asked whether someone who submitted a handful of patches 15 years ago should still qualify. He suggested requiring contributions from one of the last X releases, while warning that overly strict rules could bias the pool toward the most active contributors.

brian m. carlson also thinks the bar is too low. He said some other projects use a much tighter mechanism, and that Git should set a threshold so people are not incentivized to contribute only in order to vote. He also said contributors should not be pushed toward GitHub, since the project has historically been neutral on forges and tooling.

Junio C Hamano urged the group to resist making the rules more elaborate. He said that excluding old contributions amounts to saying more recent and current involvement deserves more influence. He warned that this logic leads to schemes like weighting votes by the age of a commit. He recommended reducing the number and complexity of conditions. He also argued that past contributors who still care about the project and know how it works would presumably be welcome to cast a vote.

Part of the exchange concerned employer influence on votes, especially around LLM policy. brian m. carlson said he does not parrot his employer's line from his personal account. Patrick Steinhardt said he works for a company in that space but is still sceptical of the technology, and that this is why he strongly feels the vote needs to be secret, so nobody fears retribution for an honest opinion. Kristoffer Haugsbakk clarified that his earlier remark concerned people paid regularly to work on Git, and only in aggregate.

No rules have been settled in the excerpts.