Harald Nordgren's patch addresses triangular workflows, where a branch is pulled from one place and pushed to another. Today git status compares the branch only with its upstream unless status.compareBranches is configured. The patch shows both comparisons by default. When the two resolve to the same branch, only one is shown, so most users would see no change. Setting status.compareBranches to "@{upstream}" restores the old output.
Phillip Wood said that anyone changing the default of a config variable should explain why the current default was chosen and why the new one is better. He asked whether the default was discussed when the variable was introduced, and said that context would make it much easier to judge the change.
Harald replied that this was fair. In a later message he also said he adapted a test and would restore closer to the old test coverage and add more.
Separately, the thread contained a side discussion on reply quoting. Wood said he trims context above his signature but leaves the original commit message in when it is relevant. Kristoffer Haugsbakk said trimming is generally recommended, and Harald said that leaving the whole message in puts cleanup on multiple responders.
The patch is at v1, and the excerpts do not show whether the maintainers favor the new default.