Re: CRLF problems with Git on Win32

On Fri, 11 Jan 2008, Steffen Prohaska wrote:

I certainly don't think "autocrlf=input" is wrong. It might even be a reasonable default on Unix, although I don't think it's nearly as obvious as the Windows case. I wouldn't mind using it myself, for example, although probably only because I know that for the stuff I work on it simply cannot possibly ever do the wrong thing.

In fact, we had a case of bogus CRLF in one of the kernel documentation files for some reason that we ended up fixing by hand. "autocflf=input" would have fixed it (except in that case it wouldn't have, since it came from the original kernel tree, long before crlf was an issue for git ;)

So I'd say that autocrlf=input is quite possibly a good idea on Unix in general, but my gut feel is still that it's not a big enough issue to be actually worth making a default change over. But there's absolutely nothing wrong with having it as a policy at a company that has mixed Unix and Windows machines.

(Every place I've ever been at, people who had a choice would never ever develop under Windows, so I've never seen any real mixing - even when some parts of the project were DOS/Windows stuff, there was a clear boundary between the stuff that was actually done under Windows)

			Linus