git-rev-parse question.

I have been looking at what git-rev-parse does and could not figure out a way to convince it to give me only arguments with a '-' prefix. Specifically, I wanted to remove the hardcoded -p and -M flags from git-diff-script. Running

    $ sh -x git-diff-script -C HEAD^ HEAD

reveals that none of the following would pick up "-C" from the command line:

    rev=($(git-rev-parse --revs-only "$@")) || exit
    flags=($(git-rev-parse --no-revs --flags "$@"))
    files=($(git-rev-parse --no-revs --no-flags "$@"))

I am not even sure if the current implementation of rev-parse matches what you originally wanted it to do; I suspect it does not. I would like to know what was the intended behaviour first, so that I can enhance it to be usable for my purpose without breaking things.

What I want the rev-parse flags to mean is as follows. By "rev argument", I mean what get_sha1() can understand. I have to admit that some flags are what I introduced while I was butchering it without really knowing the original intention:

  output format:
  --sq		output in a format usable for shell "eval".
  --symbolic	output rev argument in symbolic form, not SHA1.

  output selection:
  --flags	show only arguments with '-' prefix.
  --no-flags	do not show arguments with '-' prefix.

  --revs-only	show only arguments meant for rev-list.
  --no-revs	show arguments not meant for rev-list.

  input munging:
  --default R	if no revision, pretend R is given.
  --not		pretend all rev arguments without prefix ^ have
                prefix ^, and the ones with prefix ^ do not.
  --all		pretend all refs under $GIT_DIR/refs are given
  		on the command line.

  special:
  --verify	make sure only one rev argument is given, nothing else.

I think flags/no-flags and revs-only/no-revs *should* be orthogonal. That is, "rev-parse --flags --no-revs" should give parameters that start with '-' and not meant for rev-list (e.g. '-C' in earlier example); "rev-parse --revs-only --merge-order HEAD Documentation/" should yield "--merge-order HEAD".

Also there is an undocumented --show-prefix.  What is it?

-jc

PS. BTW, any response about unsuspecting companies?