dangling blob which is not dangling at all

Hi,

  first of all, I want to thank Linus and you all for git, it is
revolutionizing my every-day work flow. Exceptional.

Playing with my central bare git repository (yes, I am a former CVS/SVN user) and trying to lose data I discovered something I am not understanding well.

Running git fsck --no-reflogs I found some dangling objects (I have to say I enjoyed a lot in navigating commits, trees and blobs with plumbing... really!), two were commits and one was a blob.

One of the commits was there because I pushed (forcing) from a working repository after a git reset HEAD^. I checked it and removed it and all the other dependant objects until the blob which contained the new version of that file. It seems I even understood what I was doing! ;) Until here, everything had been smooth.

Second commit was something pushed from another repository but at the right head was strangely recorded with a different hash. Removing it, its tree and another sub-tree, no blob was pending. So the final blob containing the change was still used elsewhere, indeed by the "right head" of above. While I would expect this in a working repository where merging is happening all the day, it is not clear how it happened to my central repository, where nobody does any work. Any idea?

And now, what I think is a bug, the dangling blob. It is signaled as dangling but it is not. Hunting for a commit/tree/blob to compare it to in order to understand which modification it was hiding, I found a tree object which referred to it, which by definition of "dangling object" should not exist. So fsck looks f*cked... and I am well available to understand what is going wrong here, but please help me.

$ git fsck --no-reflogs dangling blob e5d444e61b834c34710ce8fb5cb176e20e5894e1 $ git-ls-tree 70b58535361eb633d44d4f1275af3421ca6a5ed7 ... 100644 blob e5d444e61b834c34710ce8fb5cb176e20e5894e1 link_stream.c ...

If you read me until here, good night! ;)

Cheers, Domenico

-----[ Domenico Andreoli, aka cavok
 --[ http://www.dandreoli.com/gpgkey.asc
   ---[ 3A0F 2F80 F79C 678A 8936  4FEE 0677 9033 A20E BC50