threads / discuss / 57730

Thanks for git and especially thanks for git add --interactive

Subject: Thanks for git and especially thanks for git add --interactive

## tl;dr

2 messages between Apr 14, 2022 and Apr 14, 2022.

replies: 1people: 2as markdown or json

demerphq· Apr 14, 2022, 04:46 UTC · lore
Hi,

I don't know who to thank directly, and I guess it is a community effort anyway, but I just wanted to thank everyone involved in making git add --interactive and its wrapper git commit --interactive. IMO it has really revolutionized my development workflow and dramatically improved the quality of the commits I create. I often spend longer using it to create a clean crafted series of patches than I have spent on making the actual changes. I have seen people describe it as an "advanced" feature, and maybe it is, but I think it is one of the *killer* features of git that has impacted the quality of commits across the industry.

git as a whole is a wonderful and fantastic tool that has obviously completely transformed the version control part of our industry, but commit interactive has completely and utterly changed how I think about writing patches and the quality of the commits I produce. It is not unusual for me to use an almost completely reverse workflow than I used to. I often create a change, not worrying too much about how I structure the commits on the way to the final state, then I squash them down to the final state I am happy with, and then work backwards to create a tailored series of commits that changes the code to that final state. That is something that I cannot imagine doing without git.

So thanks to everybody on this list, Linus, Junio, and everybody involved with making git such an awesome tool, but *especial* thanks to whomever it was that dreamed up the interactive commit modes and everyone else who worked to make it such a fantastic tool. It has literally changed my life.

cheers, Yves

-- 
perl -Mre=debug -e "/just|another|perl|hacker/"
Junio C Hamano· Apr 14, 2022, 05:04 UTC · re: demerphq · lore

Re: Thanks for git and especially thanks for git add --interactive

demerphq <demerphq@gmail.com> writes:
Show 12 quoted lines
> I don't know who to thank directly, and I guess it is a community
> effort anyway, but I just wanted to thank everyone involved in making
> ... I have seen people describe it as an
> "advanced" feature, and maybe it is, but I think it is one of the
> *killer* features of git that has impacted the quality of commits
> across the industry.
> ...
> So thanks to everybody on this list, Linus, Junio, and everybody
> involved with making git such an awesome tool, but *especial* thanks
> to whomever it was that dreamed up the interactive commit modes and
> everyone else who worked to make it such a fantastic tool. It has
> literally changed my life.
You're welcome ;-)

If you limit your search of origin to the Git land, I am reasonably sure that I am to blame for "add -i", but I'd freely admit that I stole it from darcs. They may or may not have borrowed from somewhere else, but at this point I do not really care where it came from ;-)

← back to recent threads