# Init of submodule within subtree not working

1 messages from 2019-03-13 to 2019-03-13. Participants: Thomas Kitzinger.
Thread: https://gitlist.dev/t/50730

## Thomas Kitzinger, 2019-03-13 15:06

Subject: Init of submodule within subtree not working
Message-ID: <CALYpq6_n_5kf5gFwki8cuUW=xSB80L4uoicSOL40OnohK1+h0Q@mail.gmail.com>
URL: https://gitlist.dev/e/CALYpq6_n_5kf5gFwki8cuUW%3DxSB80L4uoicSOL40OnohK1%2Bh0Q%40mail.gmail.com

```
 Hello,

currently I’m having trouble using subtree to include a subproject
that itself contains submodules.

$ git subtree add --prefix folderB/subtreeproject https:\\xx master --squash

The resulting structure is something like the following:

superproject/
├── .git/
├── .gitmodules
└── folderA/
    ├── someFileA
    └── submoduleA /
└── folderB/
    ├── someFileB
    └── subtreeproject/   <= THE SUBTREE
        ├── .gitmodules
        ├── someFolder/
        └── submoduleInSubtree/   <= THE SUBMODULE IN SUBTREE

The subtreeproject contains its own submodule and therefore its own .gitmodules.

If I now run
$ git submodule update --init --remote
I get the error
fatal: No url found for submodule path
‘folderB/subtreeproject/submoduleInSubtree’ in .gitmodules

The only way I could get the submodule initialized is by manually
copying the contents of the folder/subtreeproject/.gitmodules to the
top-level .gitmodules and adjusting the path accordingly, which is
quite annoying.

Is this behavior intended? Isn’t there a more elegant solution?

Couldn’t git respect .gitmodules not only in the root directory but
also in any sub-directory? I learned it already works for submodules
within other submodules, but apparently not for submodules within
subtrees.

My git version:
$ git version 2.21.0.windows.1


Best regards

Thomas Kitzinger

```