# git {pull,push} fails without stdin

1 messages from 2009-01-28 to 2009-01-28. Participants: Gustav Hållberg.
Thread: https://gitlist.dev/t/17411

## Gustav Hållberg, 2009-01-28 09:27

Subject: git {pull,push} fails without stdin
Message-ID: <a1e915350901280127g55d6a978i241c2b9793cc8690@mail.gmail.com>
URL: https://gitlist.dev/e/a1e915350901280127g55d6a978i241c2b9793cc8690%40mail.gmail.com

```
This was seen in git 1.6.0.2...

I want to run "git push" in an automated system and, as there's no
sensible stdin to use, I close fd 0 before exec'ing.
However, it does not work:

  sh$ git push <&-
  fatal: read error (Bad file descriptor)

compared to:

  sh$ git push
  Everything up-to-date

The same thing happens with "git pull", but not the other git commands
I tried (in a far-from-exhaustive search).

It's trivial to work around (e.g., use /dev/null as stdin), but it
would be more convenient if it just worked :-)

- Gustav

```