threads / discuss / 14969

git-rebase --merge gets stuck on --skip

Subject: git-rebase --merge gets stuck on --skip

## tl;dr

One message between Aug 13, 2008 and Aug 13, 2008.

replies: 0people: 1as markdown or json

Marius Vollmer· Aug 13, 2008, 01:51 UTC · lore
Hi,
I might have found a bug with "git-rebase --merge".

When skipping over more than one commit in a row, only the first skip has any effect. The second and subsequent skips do not change the state in .git/.dotest-merge.

This works fine with the regular git-rebase.
I use Debian's git-core 1:1.5.6.3-1.1.  I haven't tried newer versions.
How to reproduce:
  $ git clone http://zagadka.vm.bytemark.co.uk/git/project2.git
  $ cd project2/
  $ git checkout -b dev-1 origin/dev-1
  $ git rebase --merge master
  (fails with a conflict)
  $ cat .git/.dotest-merge/msgnum
  1
  $ git rebase --skip
  (fails with a different conflict)
  $ cat .git/.dotest-merge/msgnum
  1
  $ git rebase --skip
  (fails with the same conflict again)
  $ cat .git/.dotest-merge/msgnum
  1
  $ git rebase --skip
  $ cat .git/.dotest-merge/msgnum
  1
  $ git rebase --skip
  $ cat .git/.dotest-merge/msgnum
  1
  $ git rebase --skip
  $ cat .git/.dotest-merge/msgnum
  1
And so on ad infinitum...
In contrast, git-rebase without --merge eventually finishes:
  $ git clone http://zagadka.vm.bytemark.co.uk/git/project2.git
  $ cd project2/
  $ git checkout -b dev-1 origin/dev-1
  $ git rebase master
  (fails with a conflict)
  $ cat .dotest/next
  1
  $ git rebase --skip
  $ cat .dotest/next
  2
  $ git rebase --skip
  $ cat .dotest/next
  3
  $ git rebase --skip
  HEAD is now at 060b191 Master 2.
  Nothing to do.

← back to recent threads