Linus Torvalds posted a patch saying git describe does not follow its documented intent when commit dates are unreliable. In the current Linux v7.4 merge window, git describe printed v7.3-19342-g2a500a04d6f9. The kernel's localversion calculation gave 7.3.0-19059-g2a500a04d6f9. Torvalds says the kernel's number is correct and that Git's 19342 is "nonsense".
He attributes the discrepancy to git describe having walked the commit list past the actual tagged release because of date skew. The excerpt cuts off before the details of the fix.
The thread has 20 messages, with participants including Junio C Hamano, Derrick Stolee, Patrick Steinhardt, SZEDER Gábor, Tuomas Ahola and Kristofer Karlsson. The excerpts show only one recent reply, from Oswald Buddenhagen. He suspects nobody thought about this and that it results from treating committer and author dates as pseudo-atomic entities. He argues that closer consideration shows this view is not necessarily helpful, and links an earlier discussion.
The excerpts do not show whether the patch has been accepted.