Jelle van der Waa sent an RFC to teach git history reword a --verbose option, so that the full diff appears when editing the commit message, as with git commit --amend --verbose. His implementation does not follow the commit.verbose configuration setting. He said he would like to land support for reword first, ideally with commit.verbose, and add other subcommands later.

He noted that split, squash and fixup could support the option under some conditions. For fixup that would mean without --no-edit or only with --reedit-message. A second patch removes a redundant strbuf_stripspace() call, since cleanup_message() with COMMIT_MSG_CLEANUP_ALL already does it.

D. Ben Knoble replied with a first thought on naming. Consistency with other commands is good, he said, but "verbose" might be better reserved for another meaning in git-history. He said he has sometimes wished the command would show the rewritten commits after running, in a form like "commit abc => def".

Because "verbose" can mean many things, he suggested something like --commit-verbose, --diff-in-editor or another name that makes the purpose clear. The thread had four messages and no other comments in the excerpts.