From: Jakub Narebski <jnareb@gmail.com>
Date: Tue, 24 Jun 2008 23:28:22 GMT
Subject: Re: Windows symlinks
Message-ID: <m3od5qjtv1.fsf@localhost.localdomain>
In-Reply-To: <911589C97062424796D53B625CEC0025E4618F@USCOBRMFA-SE-70.northamerica.cexp.com>

Patrick Higgins <Patrick.Higgins@cexp.com> writes:

> It looks like one of the bigger (biggest?) hurdles for git adoption
> at my company is going to be handling symlinks on Windows. We may be
> able to sidestep the issue [...] by [...] run[ning] Linux
> in a virtual machine [...]

If only MS Windows supported other filesystems which have symlinks...

> Has anyone thought about a way for git to handle symlinks? Vista
> seems to have added native symlinks, but you need have elevated
> privilege to create them. NTFS junction points seem helpful for
> older versions of Windows, but don't work for anything except
> directories, and seem to be dangerous to use with tools that do
> recursive deletes. Neither junction points nor native symlinks sound
> like great options.
> 
> Cygwin's clever symlink trick seems to work pretty well in
> practice. I'm not exactly sure what it's doing, but it seems to
> create a shortcut that it's own programs understand. Some other
> non-Cygwin programs seem to understand them, too, but Java does not
> which is a big problem for me.

First, I think that both "git on Windows" solutions, namely Cygwin and
msysGit port, don't use symlinks either in installed programs, nor in
repository layout.

Second, the problem there can be _only_ if your repository contains
(or contained) symlinks, and then it is your own damn fault.  I don't
know how Cygwin, or msysGit deals with symlinks in a wirking
directory, but you can work around symlinks (although in a bit
unwieldy way) by using `core.symlinks' configuration variable;
see git-config(1):

 core.symlinks::
        If false, symbolic links are checked out as small plain files
        that contain the link text. git-update-index(1) and git-add(1)
        will not change the recorded type to regular file. Useful on
        filesystems like FAT that do not support symbolic links. True
        by default.

-- 
Jakub Narebski
Poland
ShadeHawk on #git