From: Erik Cervin Edin <erik@cervined.in>
Date: Thu, 14 May 2026 15:40:34 GMT
Subject: Re: [PATCH] git-jump: pick a mode automatically when invoked without arguments
Message-ID: <agXb1SXKnA69L9ak@mbp>
In-Reply-To: <20260508175240.GA737125@coredump.intra.peff.net>

On 26/05/08 04:30PM, Greg Hurrell wrote:
> Hopefully, they at least read the README before installing it from contrib/
> (although Homebrew recently starting installing it for folks automatically,
> so may not remain true for much longer on macOS...)

Oh! I didn't know that but looking closer on my homebrew installed Git,
looks like you're right.

I would've assumed that if users had jumped through the hoops of
installing git-jump from contrib/ it stands to reason they would have
some sense of what it does. But if this is landing as a part of regular
brew install git, I'd wager there's a few unsuspecting people running
git-jump that don't know what it does.

> Would having "git jump auto" work for you?

Imo, this sounds ideal -- there's something odd about `git jump` picking
the subcommand heuristically. At least when I invoke git-jump I always
do so with a specific intent of _where_ I want to jump. Then again, I
never do a jump merge or a jump ws.

> Homebrew installing `git-jump` by default a few months ago[^2] broke
> this, because aliases can't shadow builtin commands.

But it looks like this doesn't work in this case. Even if you have
git-jump installed stand-alone (mine is in ~/bin/git-jump, in PATH,
before /opt/homebrew/bin.)

FWIW I alias jump to j, jump diff to jd and jump grep to jg. E.g.

    git jd # git jump diff

On 26/05/08 09:07AM, Greg Hurrell via GitGitGadget wrote:
> -usage: git jump [--stdout] <mode> [<args>]
> +usage: git jump [--stdout] [<mode>] [<args>]

The usage message makes <mode> optional but doesn't explain what
happens when you omit it. Seems worth documenting the auto-detect behavior
there too.

> But there are two situations where we can usefully infer the most
> valuable and likely mode that a user would want to use, and select it
> automatically when they run `git jump` without arguments:
>
> 1. When there are unmerged paths in the index, the user likely
>    wants `git jump merge`.
>
> 2. When the working tree has unstaged changes, the user likely
>    wants `git jump diff`.

I can think of a third situation -- when there are staged changes flagged by
git diff --cached --check.

If we're going to teach git-jump how to be more clever about where to jump,
does it also make sense to bake `git jump ws` into this?

Also, if this is going to grow into a proper auto-detect heuristic, it
might be cleaner as a first-class mode rather than logic spliced into the
argument parser. Something like:

    mode_auto() {
        if test -n "$(git ls-files -u)"; then
            mode_merge "$@"
        elif ! git diff --quiet; then
            mode_diff "$@"
        elif ! git diff --cached --check >/dev/null 2>&1; then
            mode_ws --cached "$@"
        else
            return 0
        fi
    }

That way `git jump auto` works explicitly, bare `git jump` defaults
to it (just `set -- auto` when $# -lt 1), and the usage text can
document the heuristic. It also keeps the detection and dispatch in
one place in case someone wants to tweak the priority later.

All in all, I think an auto jumping mode could be genuinely useful.