From: Phillip Wood <phillip.wood123@gmail.com>
Date: Wed, 10 Sep 2025 09:52:44 GMT
Subject: Re: Git Stash Synchronization - Best Workflow?
Message-ID: <94d614fb-63b8-4733-b78d-b55c482fbed8@gmail.com>
In-Reply-To: <FEB150D4-2B5E-41CF-ADCE-93DD0B48D364@alchemists.io>

Hi Brooke

On 06/09/2025 13:50, Brooke Kuhlmann wrote:
>> That sounds like a bug if you're getting the rejected message above
>> but the ref on the remote is still being updated. I'll try and take
>> a look at that next week.

I'm unable to reproduce this. In the script below the final push succeeds.

     set -ex
     dir="$(mktemp -d)"
     cd "$dir"
     git init --bare origin
     git init repo
     cd repo
     git remote add origin "file://${PWD%/*}/origin"
     git config core.logAllRefUpdates always
     git config remote.origin.fetch refs/stashes/*:refs/remote/origin/stashes/*
     echo a >a
     git add a
     git commit -m a
     echo b >a
     git stash push
     echo c >a
     git stash push
     git stash export --to-ref refs/stashes/test
     git push origin refs/stashes/test
     git stash pop
     git stash push -m message
     git stash export --to-ref refs/stashes/test
     git push --force-with-lease --force-if-includes  origin refs/stashes/test

>> You need to pass the name of the ref whose reflog you want to look at,
>> otherwise it defaults to showing the reflog for HEAD. You should be
>> able to see the reflog for you exported stashes.> 
> I gave this a try and every time I use `git reflog refs/stashes/$USER`,
>  I always get a blank response. No errors and no output.
Ah, I wonder if core.logAllRefUpdates only affects the creation of new
refs. You can force the creation of a reflog by running

	oid=$(git rev-parse --verify refs/stashes/$USER) &&
	git update-ref -d refs/stashes/$USER &&
	git update-ref --create-reflog -m 'export stashes' refs/stashes/$USER $oid

the same applies to refs/remote/stashes/origin/$USER

>> Let's try and find why the remote update say's it rejected when it isn't
>> and then we can think about the best way to document pushing and
>> pulling exported stashes.
I haven't thought much about the pulling side of this. "git stash import"
appends to the existing stashes so I'm not sure how we'd cope with forced
updates - have got got any experience of handling this from your
experiments?

Thanks

Phillip