From: Toon Claes Date: Thu, 09 Jul 2026 09:53:06 GMT Subject: Re: [PATCH v3 4/5] builtin/refs: add "create" subcommand Message-ID: <87zf00mqv1.fsf@emacs.iotcl.com> In-Reply-To: Patrick Steinhardt writes: > On Fri, Jul 03, 2026 at 04:19:58PM +0200, Toon Claes wrote: >> Patrick Steinhardt writes: >> > diff --git a/Documentation/git-refs.adoc b/Documentation/git-refs.adoc >> > index 6475bdcc62..e6a3528349 100644 >> > --- a/Documentation/git-refs.adoc >> > +++ b/Documentation/git-refs.adoc >> > @@ -181,6 +184,53 @@ static int cmd_refs_optimize(int argc, const char **argv, const char *prefix, >> > return pack_refs_core(argc, argv, prefix, repo, refs_optimize_usage); >> > } >> > >> > +static int cmd_refs_create(int argc, const char **argv, const char *prefix, >> > + struct repository *repo) >> > +{ >> > + static char const * const refs_create_usage[] = { >> > + REFS_CREATE_USAGE, >> > + NULL >> > + }; >> > + const char *message = NULL; >> > + unsigned flags = 0; >> > + struct option opts[] = { >> > + OPT_STRING(0, "message", &message, N_("reason"), >> > + N_("reason of the update")), >> > + OPT_BIT(0 ,"no-deref", &flags, >> > + N_("update not the one it points to"), >> > + REF_NO_DEREF), >> >> Can `git refs create --no-deref` be used to create symrefs? Should we >> add a test for that? Or can it not >> >> I understand the symmetry, but does it make sense to ask the user to >> create symrefs with `--no-deref`? Feels a bit obscure. The docs say: >> >> `--no-deref`:: >> Operate on itself rather than the reference it points to via a >> symbolic ref. >> >> That's far from obvious for a user to realize they need to pass that >> option if they want to create a symref. > > It doesn't cause them to create a symref. What this flag controls is > whether the command would fail when the refname exists already as a > symbolic ref. That is: > > $ git symbolic-ref refs/heads/symref refs/heads/target > $ git refs create refs/heads/symref $OID > $ git refs exists refs/heads/target That makes sense. Sort of. So passing `--no-deref` to `git refs create` in the example above would make sense if you want creation of refs/heads/target to fail. Okay, doesn't seem very obvious, but feels correct. > The git-refs(1) command would have created "refs/heads/target" in this > case, and by passing "--no-deref" you'd instead make it fail. > > This flag is somewhat weird. Having it is probably a sensible think to > do, but now that I think about it I wonder whether the default makes all > that much sense in the first place. That being said, _if_ we want to > change it then we should change it for all subcommands. Not sure how to make it better, so let's leave it like this. >> > diff --git a/t/t1466-refs-create.sh b/t/t1466-refs-create.sh >> > new file mode 100755 >> > index 0000000000..cfb21bf863 >> > --- /dev/null >> > +++ b/t/t1466-refs-create.sh >> > @@ -0,0 +1,151 @@ > [snip] >> > +test_expect_success 'create fails when the reference already exists' ' >> > + test_when_finished "rm -rf repo" && >> > + setup_repo repo && >> > + ( >> > + cd repo && >> > + A=$(git rev-parse A) && >> > + B=$(git rev-parse B) && >> > + git refs create refs/heads/foo $A && >> > + test_must_fail git refs create refs/heads/foo $B 2>err && >> > + test_grep "reference already exists" err && >> > + test_ref_matches refs/heads/foo "$A" >> > + ) >> > +' >> >> I was curious about this test: >> >> test_expect_success 'create succeed when the reference exists with the same value' ' >> test_when_finished "rm -rf repo" && >> setup_repo repo && >> ( >> cd repo && >> A=$(git rev-parse A) && >> git refs create refs/heads/foo $A && >> git refs create refs/heads/foo $A && >> test_ref_matches refs/heads/foo "$A" >> ) >> ' >> >> That fails. It that intentional? > > Yes, this is intentional. We didn't end up creating the reference, which > is what the user has asked us to do, and hence we fail. Understood. >> > +test_expect_success 'create with symref target and --no-deref refuses to create reference' ' >> > + test_when_finished "rm -rf repo" && >> > + setup_repo repo && >> > + ( >> > + cd repo && >> > + A=$(git rev-parse A) && >> > + git symbolic-ref refs/heads/symref refs/heads/target && >> > + test_must_fail git refs create --no-deref refs/heads/symref $A 2>err && >> > + test_grep "dangling symref already exists" err && >> > + test_must_fail git reflog exists refs/heads/target >> > + ) >> > +' >> >> Would it make sense to add this test: >> >> test_expect_success 'create with symref target with --no-deref' ' >> test_when_finished "rm -rf repo" && >> setup_repo repo && >> ( >> cd repo && >> A=$(git rev-parse A) && >> git refs create refs/heads/target $A && >> git refs create --no-deref refs/heads/symref refs/heads/target && >> git reflog exists refs/heads/symref && false >> ) >> ' >> >> But that makes me think, this option `--no-deref` is pretty obscure for >> use with `git refs create`. There are two situations: >> >> * The symref doesn't exists: so --no-deref basically is forcing the >> command to create a symref. That's confusing > > No, it's not. It tells us that we only want to create the reference if > it doesn't exist and is not a symref. Otherwise, we'd potentially create > the reference that the symref is pointing to. Okay, I better understand now with the example above. Thanks! -- Cheers, Toon