From: Sergey Organov <sorganov@gmail.com>
Date: Wed, 01 Oct 2025 20:22:23 GMT
Subject: Re: What is the reason behind not hiding git worktrees from git?
Message-ID: <875xcyfk3k.fsf@osv.gnss.ru>
In-Reply-To: <xmqq3482312r.fsf@gitster.g>

Junio C Hamano <gitster@pobox.com> writes:

> Ben Knoble <ben.knoble@gmail.com> writes:
>
>>> The impact is that the list of worktrees would have to be read to get
>>> status. As status is not particularly cheap operation in any case I
>>> would expect the problem to be minor.
>>
>> I believe status information is used for the shell prompt info, so
>> performance hits there have a cost.
>
> Sure, but an embedded git-controlled working tree _should_ be
> flagged as an untracked entity, _unless_ it is ignore'd, no?
>
> That is how you would add a new submodule to your project after all.
> So, if you want to ignore them, just add them to .git/info/exclude
> or something, perhaps?
>
> Why do people even want to have such a layout, unless they want to
> make it a submodule (or deliberate subdirectory that is unrelated)?
>
>  -+- README.md (your own branch, probably on main)
>   |
>   +-+ worktree-foo (worktree checkout of branch foo)
>   | |
>   | +-- README.md (a slight variant of the file in foo)
>   |
>   +-+ worktree-bar (worktree checkout of branch bar)
>   | |
>   | +-- README.md (a slight variant of the file in bar)
>   |
>   +-+ worktree-baz (worktree checkout of branch baz)
>   | |
>   | +-- README.md (a slight variant of the file in baz)
>
> Wouldn't it be easier to manage if you had this instead?
>
>  -+
>   |
>   +-+ my-project (the primary worktree, probably on main)
>   | |
>   | +-- README.md (the file from branch main)
>   |
>   +-+ worktree-foo (worktree checkout of branch foo)
>   | |
>   | +-- README.md (a slight variant of the file in foo)
>   |
>   +-+ worktree-bar (worktree checkout of branch bar)
>   | |
>   | +-- README.md (a slight variant of the file in bar)
>   |
>   +-+ worktree-baz (worktree checkout of branch baz)
>   | |
>   | +-- README.md (a slight variant of the file in baz)
>
> That way, you can go up to the umbrella directory and ...
>
>     $ cd ..
>     $ ls
>     my-project worktree-foo worktree-bar worktree-baz
>     $ grep -e HowTo */README.md
>
> ... do things you would do collectively to these worktrees with the
> primary worktree included as well.

I suspect people rather expect support for repository with multiple
equal worktrees (no "primary" one), like this:

myproject / .git
          / worktree-foo
          / worktree-bar


Also, I'm almost sure that the first thing almost every worktree novice
does (I did), quite naturally, is:

$ git wotktree add <branch>

that happily succeeds /anywhere/ inside primary worktree without any
warning for me. It probably should either have created $top/../<branch>
instead, or refuse to proceed without confirmation in the first place.

-- Sergey Organov