From: Phillip Wood Date: Mon, 02 Nov 2026 16:34:23 GMT Subject: Re: Ejecting things more aggressively out of 'seen'? Message-ID: <48a6c039-75b6-4fa4-a18e-ea3240037be9@gmail.com> In-Reply-To: On 02/11/2026 16:17, Junio C Hamano wrote: > Patrick Steinhardt writes: > >> One state that confuses newcomers quite often is "Will merge to 'next'?" >> with a question mark at the end. If we were to document these we shuld >> probably also document that state. > > Hmph, really? Just like the subject of this e-mail message, a > trailing question mark is my way of saying "I am planning to do > this, but if you think it is a bad idea, please stop me with an > explanation why I shouldn't". The subject of this message feels more like a question, whereas it sounds like "Will merge to next?" means "I'm going to do that unless someone stops me" rather than "do others think this is ready for next?" >>> - A topic goes into the "Waiting for response" state once reviewed, >>> where it remains until the author responds. After staying in >>> this state for a month or so, it is demoted to the "Stalled" >>> state, and eventually dropped. >>> >>> We should probably have a rule that says "a topic that did not get >>> reviewed for N weeks is ejected from 'seen'". >> >> I think that's reasonable. Becoming a bit more aggressive there doesn't >> make too much of a difference anyway -- if a topic gets evicted from >> "seen" and then later on regains interest then it can still be included >> into "seen" again. Indeed >> By gut feeling I'd use the same rule as for "Waiting for response". Perhaps making it clear that when a topic is ejected it can be re-added if there is renewed interest in it would lessen any worry about demotivating contributors? Thanks Phillip > An obvious alternative is to queue only topics for which I can, by > judging reviews on the list, at least say "Will merge to 'next'?" > with enough confidence. It would reduce the size of 'seen' and the > friction felt by contributors when their topic is once queued on > 'seen' and later ejected unceremoniously through no fault of their > own, other than their topic being forgettable or uninspiring to > others. > > I do not know which one is better: educating contributors that their > topics being uninspiring to others is something they should not feel > bad about and giving our reviewers easier access to these candidate > topics, or being strict and mechanical and queuing only topics that > some human reviewers with a certain level of reputation have looked > at and have not just shown interest in, but have said are ready. > > I can do either. It is less emotional stress for me to do the > latter. Between hitting 'seen' and then later being discarded, and > not getting any response or reaction at all, I am not sure which one > our contributors find more acceptable.