From: Hal Eisen <eisen@dunhackin.org>
Date: Thu, 08 Jul 2010 01:50:19 GMT
Subject: Question about git revert
Message-ID: <20100708015019.GP10042@volcano.builtonlinux.com>

I did a search of the archives for this mailing list, and couldn't
find anything applicable.

I am having the same problem as Joshua Cheek.  He asked this question
on StackOverflow about a month ago.

http://stackoverflow.com/questions/2938301/git-remove-specific-commit

There are no merges involved.  I would be perfectly happy having
another commit in my history which documents the reverting of a prior
commit.

The problem seems to stem from git-revert not properly calculating the
"cleanness" of the prior commit, and incorrectly thinking that later
commits depend on the to-be-reverted commit.

I have seen other web sites which suggest using git to manually
generate a diff, and then applying it as a reverse patch, but that
seems like a kludge.

What is the best solution for this use case?

Thanks,
Hal