From: Dave Watson <dwatson@mimvista.com>
Date: Fri, 09 May 2008 02:29:37 GMT
Subject: Re: Java Git (aka jgit) library switching license to BSD/EPL
Message-ID: <1CC65F01-3F34-4DE9-9AB8-BAB2F1C22723@mimvista.com>
In-Reply-To: <20080509021158.GA29038@spearce.org>

I have no objection to the relicense, if it will help things out.

--
Dave Watson
Director of Software Development
MIMvista Corp.

On May 8, 2008, at 10:11 PM, "Shawn O. Pearce" <spearce@spearce.org>  
wrote:

> The Java Git library (also known as "jgit"[*1*]) is a 100% pure Java
> implementation of a data access library for the Git on-disk data
> structures, as well as a re-implementation of some commonly used
> application functions such as history graph traversal/visualization
> and network transport (fetch).
>
> Since its inception on March 6, 2006 jgit has been under the
> GPLv2 license.  To make the library available to a wider audience
> (including but not limited to the Eclipse Git plugin, numerous
> Apache projects such as Ant/Maven, the Netbeans IDE, etc.) we are
> switching to a dual license between a 3-clause BSD (the EDL[*2*])
> and the EPL[*3*].
>
> As of the bleeding edge (40c5c6cb11b8cc6caf3ea6a681caf0a6b8d66f36
> [*4*]) the ownership of all currently surviving lines of code is
> broken down as follows:
>
>   $ sh owner.sh
>    78%   27607 Shawn O. Pearce
>    17%    6061 Robin Rosenberg
>     4%    1518 Dave Watson
>     0%       4 Thad Hughes
>     0%       2 Roger C. Soares
>   ------------------------------
>   100%   35192 total
>
> Robin and Dave:
>
>  With 17% and 4% ownership, can you please reply to verify
>  this license change will be permitted for your contributions?
>  Please note this change is _only_ to jgit, and not to the egit
>  (Eclipse plugin) code.
>
> Nico, Linus, Junio, Daniel, Dscho, et.al.:
>
>  We would appreciate it if you could provide a statement saying
>  you have no current copyright ownership interest in jgit, and that
>  you do not currently own nor invented any patents related to the
>  "Git technology" that this code might need to use to function as
>  a Git implementation.
>
>  Part of the application process for EGit to become a project
>  under the umbrella of the Eclipse Foundation[*5*] requires us
>  to be reasonably certain the source code we are contributing is
>  free of claims that could be brought by a 3rd party.  A statement
>  from major contributors to C Git (those who created much of the
>  C implementation) would show those individuals have no claims
>  to bring against the current version of jgit, and that jgit is
>  therefore likely to be free of any IP claims.
>
>  There are three particular sections of jgit code that I would
>  like to bring to your attention before you respond:
>
>    * BinaryDelta[*6*] bears a striking simiarlity to patch-delta.c.
>    * PackFetchConnection[*7*] does what builtin-fetch-pack.c does.
>    * IndexPack[*8*] does what index-pack.c does.
>
>  Here (and everywhere else in jgit) we have tried to avoid directly
>  translating C->Java, but sometimes things just come out in a
>  similar way once expressed in source form.  Knowing both the jgit
>  and C git code well I think these are the closest sections where
>  someone might suspect jgit copied code from C git.  The attached
>  owner.sh script applied to those three files in C git came up
>  with the following major contributors:
>
>       33%     616 Nicolas Pitre
>       16%     304 Junio C Hamano
>       13%     241 Johannes Schindelin
>       10%     197 Sergey Vlasov
>        5%     107 Linus Torvalds
>        5%     105 Shawn O. Pearce
>        5%      94 Martin Koegler
>        3%      71 Daniel Barkalow
>        2%      40 Johannes Sixt
>        1%      36 Geert Bosch
>
>
> *1*  http://repo.or.cz/w/egit.git
> *2*  http://www.eclipse.org/org/documents/edl-v10.php
> *3*  http://www.eclipse.org/org/documents/epl-v10.php
> *4*  http://repo.or.cz/w/egit/spearce.git
> *5*  http://wiki.eclipse.org/EGit/Proposal
>
> *6*  http://repo.or.cz/w/egit/spearce.git?a=blob;f=org.spearce.jgit/src/org/spearce/jgit/lib/BinaryDelta.java;h=bba6b19a4000923abfe57b844bae17e7a03e0419;hb=40c5c6cb11b8cc6caf3ea6a681caf0a6b8d66f36
> *7*  http://repo.or.cz/w/egit/spearce.git?a=blob;f=org.spearce.jgit/src/org/spearce/jgit/transport/PackFetchConnection.java;h=c7fa66c0654eaf84c143e61ee4d11b74d73db28f;hb=40c5c6cb11b8cc6caf3ea6a681caf0a6b8d66f36
> *8*  http://repo.or.cz/w/egit/spearce.git?a=blob;f=org.spearce.jgit/src/org/spearce/jgit/transport/IndexPack.java;h=b6e5956f62fa8cb60770c991699ae7b457d8954f;hb=40c5c6cb11b8cc6caf3ea6a681caf0a6b8d66f36
>
> --8< owner.sh --
> #!/bin/sh
>
> for f in $(git ls-files \
>    jgit \
>    org.spearce.jgit \
>    org.spearce.jgit.test \
>    | egrep -v '.(launch|pack|idx)$' \
>    | egrep -v ^org.spearce.jgit/lib/ \
>    )
> do
>    git blame -C -C --whitespace "$f"
> done | perl -e '
>    $total = 0;
>    while (<>) {
>        die "$_\n" unless
>        /^[0-9a-f]+ (?:[^)]+)?\((.*?) \d{4}-\d{2}-\d{2} /;
>        $n = $1;
>        $n =~ s/^\s+//;
>        $n =~ s/\s+$//;
>        $who{$n}++;
>        $total++;
>    }
>    @own = map {[$_, $who{$_}, $who{$_} * 100 / $total]} keys %who;
>    $fnd = 0;
>    foreach (sort {$b->[2] <=> $a->[2]} @own) {
>        $fnd += $_->[1];
>        printf "%3i%% %7i %s\n", $_->[2], $_->[1], $_->[0];
>    }
>    $unk = $total - $fnd;
>    print "-" x 30, "\n";
>    if ($unk > 0) {
>        printf "%3i%% %7i (unknown)\n", $unk * 100 / $total, $unk;
>    }
>    printf "%3i%% %7i total\n", 100, $total;
> '
>
> -- 
> Shawn.