{"thread":{"id":"66149","subject":"AI Textconv filter misconfiguration on Windows leads to silent corruption of diff output (ongoing investigation)","startedAt":"2026-08-11T00:44:45Z","lastAt":"2026-09-02T19:43:37Z","messageCount":16,"participants":["Skybuck Flying","Jeff King","Theodore Tso","Bradley Morgan","rsbecker@nexbridge.com","D. Ben Knoble"],"isPatch":false,"patchVersion":null,"patchTotal":null},"messages":[{"id":"550228","messageId":"AM0PR02MB445096594555DAD1D9EE1505B3DD2@AM0PR02MB4450.eurprd02.prod.outlook.com","threadId":"66149","inReplyTo":null,"subject":"AI Textconv filter misconfiguration on Windows leads to silent corruption of diff output (ongoing investigation)","fromName":"Skybuck Flying","fromEmail":"skybuck2000@hotmail.com","sentAt":"2026-08-11T00:44:42Z","receivedAt":"2026-08-11T00:44:45Z","isPatch":false,"body":"Dear Git maintainers,\n\nI am writing to report a highly confusing and time‑consuming issue that I have encountered while using Git on Windows. The problem involves Git's textconv mechanism, the bundled sed, and a seemingly harmless configuration intended to remove carriage returns (CR) before displaying diffs. The issue is still under investigation, and I have not yet applied a definitive solution, but I believe it is worth reporting because it can cause massive confusion and wasted time for other users.\n\nBackground\n\nI am working on a private branch of a Go project on Windows 10 (Git version 2.x, installed at C:\\Tools\\Git). I noticed that git diff between two commits (e.g., 429c244..70f57a8) showed added lines containing corrupt identifiers. For example:\n\n- compareCache appeared as compaeCache\n- return appeared as eturn\n- from appeared as fom\n- var appeared as va\n- for appeared as fo\n- cacheReader appeared as cacheReade\n- CompareAndSwap appeared as CompaeAndSwap\n\nThe repository itself was clean. Extracting the actual file content from the commit with git show <commit>:net/sync_cache_reader.go correctly showed the proper spelling (e.g., compareCache). Running git diff --no-textconv produced the correct diff, proving that the corruption was introduced by a textconv filter.\n\nConfiguration\n\nI had configured a textconv filter to normalize line endings before displaying diffs. Importantly, this configuration was not manually created by me; it was suggested by an AI assistant (specifically GitHub Copilot) while I was trying to solve a different problem with line endings. The AI recommended adding:\n\nGlobal .gitconfig:\ndiff.lfclean.textconv=sed -e s/\\r//\n\n.gitattributes (in the repository):\n*.go diff=lfclean\n\nThe intention was to remove carriage return (CR) characters from files before diffing, to avoid seeing ^M in the output.\n\nThis is a beautiful example of how AI can create confusion – the advice seemed perfectly reasonable but led to silent corruption of diffs, wasting many hours of debugging.\n\nObserved Behavior\n\n- git diff (with the filter active) shows corrupted output (missing the letter 'r').\n- git diff --no-textconv shows correct output.\n- git show <commit>:<file> shows correct content.\n- git status shows no modifications; the working tree is clean.\n\nThus, the repository is not corrupt; the diff presentation is being altered.\n\nInitial Diagnosis\n\nI suspected that sed was misinterpreting the \\r escape sequence. I found that Git for Windows bundles its own sed (at C:\\Tools\\Git\\usr\\bin\\sed.exe), which is used even when sed is not in the system %PATH%. Running the command directly:\n\necho compareCache | C:\\Tools\\Git\\usr\\bin\\sed.exe -e s/\\r//\n\noutputs:\n\ncompaeCache\n\nSo the command does strip the literal character 'r' instead of carriage returns. The likely reason is that the backslash before r is not preserved through the shell argument parsing on Windows; effectively, the expression becomes s/r//, which deletes all 'r' characters.\n\nImpact\n\n- Diff output becomes unreliable; users may falsely suspect repository corruption.\n- Debugging is extremely time‑consuming. In my case, several hours were wasted, involving multiple tools and even AI assistants, before the root cause was identified.\n- The problem is silent – no error messages are shown, making it hard to detect.\n- This case also highlights a risk of relying on AI‑generated Git configurations without fully understanding the platform‑specific pitfalls.\n\nCurrent Status\n\nI have not yet decided on a permanent fix. I am considering removing the filter entirely, replacing it with a safer command (e.g., tr -d \\r), or using --no-textconv when needed. However, I wanted to report this to the mailing list to:\n\n1. Warn other Windows users about this pitfall, especially when taking advice from AI assistants.\n2. Suggest possible improvements to Git to prevent such confusion in the future.\n\nSuggested Improvements\n\n- Documentation: Add a warning to gitattributes and git-config about using backslash escapes in textconv commands on Windows. Provide safe examples for removing CR, such as:\n  diff.lfclean.textconv=tr -d \\r\n  or\n  diff.lfclean.textconv=dos2unix\n\n- Built-in filter: Consider offering a built-in textconv filter for line-ending normalization, e.g., diff.lfclean.textconv=git-crlf-remove, which would robustly handle CR stripping without relying on external tools or escaping pitfalls.\n\n- Debugging aid: Add a flag like --debug-textconv that logs the exact command being executed for a textconv filter. This would help users see that their configured command may not be what they expect.\n\n- Warning for suspicious patterns: On Windows, Git could detect textconv commands containing \\r and emit a warning that this may be misinterpreted, suggesting safer alternatives.\n\nWorkaround for Affected Users\n\nRemove the faulty filter:\ngit config --global --unset diff.lfclean.textconv\nand delete or comment out the line in .gitattributes.\n\nAlternatively, use git diff --no-textconv to bypass the filter when needed.\n\nConclusion\n\nThis issue is a result of a common misconfiguration combined with the quirks of Windows command parsing and the bundled sed. While Git itself is not at fault, better documentation and maybe a built-in solution would greatly improve the user experience for Windows developers. Additionally, this incident serves as a cautionary tale about relying on AI‑generated advice for system‑level configurations without understanding the underlying platform specifics.\n\nI am happy to assist with testing any proposed documentation changes or additional debugging features. Thank you for your consideration.\n\nYours sincerely,\n  Skybuck Flying (skybuck2000@hotmail.com)\n\nPersonal note: I BLAME LINUX FOR NOT FOLLOWING THE CARRIAGE RETURN NEW LINE CONVENTION. I ALSO BLAME/DISLIKE WINDOWS 11 ENVIRONMENT DIALOG PATH 2047 LIMIT WHICH MIGHT FURTHER CONFUSE THINGS, RE-ORDERING OF PATHS ALSO OCCURED BY AI TO TRY AND SOLVE THIS PATH DIALOG GUI LIMITATION ISSUE, LONGER PATH WAS SET DIRECTLY INTO THE REGISTRY.\n\n"},{"id":"550229","messageId":"AM0PR02MB445083767BAE669D4656CA6CB3DD2@AM0PR02MB4450.eurprd02.prod.outlook.com","threadId":"66149","inReplyTo":"AM0PR02MB445096594555DAD1D9EE1505B3DD2@AM0PR02MB4450.eurprd02.prod.outlook.com","subject":"Re: AI Textconv filter misconfiguration on Windows leads to silent corruption of diff output (ongoing investigation)","fromName":"Skybuck Flying","fromEmail":"skybuck2000@hotmail.com","sentAt":"2026-08-11T02:13:25Z","receivedAt":"2026-08-11T02:13:28Z","isPatch":false,"body":"I confronted Co-Pilot with it, according to Co-Pilot you will like this shorter report better, more to the point:\n\nHi,\n\nI encountered an issue on Windows where a textconv filter intended to strip\ncarriage returns ends up corrupting diff output by removing literal 'r'\ncharacters.\n\nConfiguration:\n\n    [diff \"lfclean\"]\n        textconv = sed -e s/\\r//\n    *.go diff=lfclean\n\nEnvironment:\n- Windows 10\n- Git for Windows (2.x)\n- sed from Git for Windows: usr/bin/sed.exe\n\nProblem:\nRunning `git diff` on Go source files shows corrupted identifiers:\n    compareCache → compaeCache\n    return → eturn\n    for → fo\n    cacheReader → cacheReade\netc.\n\nThe repository content is correct:\n- `git diff --no-textconv` shows correct diffs.\n- `git show <commit>:<file>` shows correct content.\n\nReproduction outside Git:\n\n    echo compareCache | C:\\Tools\\Git\\usr\\bin\\sed.exe -e s/\\r//\n\nOutput:\n\n    compaeCache\n\nSo sed removes literal 'r' instead of carriage returns. It appears that on\nWindows, the backslash in `\\r` is not preserved through MSYS argument parsing,\neffectively turning the expression into `s/r//`.\n\nImpact:\n- Diff output becomes misleading/corrupted.\n- No warning is emitted.\n- The issue is silent and difficult to diagnose.\n\nSuggestion:\n- Consider documenting that sed-based textconv filters using backslash escapes\n  are unsafe on Windows.\n- Possibly warn when textconv commands contain `\\r` on Windows.\n- A built-in CR-stripping textconv filter would avoid these pitfalls.\n\nThanks,\n  Skybuck Flying\n\n\n"},{"id":"550230","messageId":"AM0PR02MB445013B3CDAAAD361FD93A86B3DD2@AM0PR02MB4450.eurprd02.prod.outlook.com","threadId":"66149","inReplyTo":"AM0PR02MB445083767BAE669D4656CA6CB3DD2@AM0PR02MB4450.eurprd02.prod.outlook.com","subject":"Re: AI Textconv filter misconfiguration on Windows leads to silent corruption of diff output (ongoing investigation)","fromName":"Skybuck Flying","fromEmail":"skybuck2000@hotmail.com","sentAt":"2026-08-11T02:19:34Z","receivedAt":"2026-08-11T02:19:37Z","isPatch":false,"body":"Perfectly confusing, I will just continue spamming until the fucking AI figures out, I am not wasting one single brain cell in this mess:\n\nTo: git@vger.kernel.org\nSubject: Windows: textconv pipeline corrupts diff output (sed not at fault)\n\nDear Git maintainers,\n\nI would like to report an extremely confusing and time‑consuming issue involving\nGit’s textconv mechanism on Windows. The problem causes *silent corruption* of\ndiff output, leading to hours of wasted debugging and false suspicion of\nrepository damage.\n\nThis is not a sed bug, not a shell bug, and not a user error. It is a problem\ninside Git’s textconv pipeline on Windows.\n\nEnvironment:\n- Windows 10\n- Git for Windows (2.x)\n- sed.exe from Git for Windows (usr/bin/sed.exe)\n- textconv filter configured via .gitattributes\n\nSymptoms:\nWhen diffing Go source files, Git shows corrupted identifiers such as:\n\n    compareCache  → compaeCache\n    return        → eturn\n    for           → fo\n    cacheReader   → cacheReade\n\nImportant:\n- The repository content is correct.\n- `git diff --no-textconv` shows correct output.\n- `git show <commit>:<file>` shows correct content.\n- The working tree is clean.\n- Running sed manually on Windows behaves correctly and does NOT corrupt text.\n\nIn other words: the corruption happens *only* inside Git’s textconv execution\npath.\n\nRoot cause (confirmed):\nGit’s textconv pipeline on Windows is altering the output of the filter in a way\nthat removes characters from the diff. The corruption cannot be reproduced by\nrunning sed.exe directly from cmd.exe or PowerShell. It only occurs when Git\ninvokes the filter.\n\nThis makes the issue extremely difficult to diagnose, because:\n- The filter command appears harmless.\n- The external tool behaves correctly when tested manually.\n- Git emits no warnings.\n- The corruption is silent and misleading.\n\nImpact:\nThis problem is incredibly frustrating for users. It creates the illusion of\nrepository corruption, breaks trust in diff output, and wastes hours of\ndebugging time. In my case, I spent a long time chasing phantom bugs in Go code\nbefore discovering that Git itself was altering the diff output.\n\nRequest:\nI would like to ask the Git for Windows maintainers to investigate the\ntextconv execution path, specifically how filter output is captured and passed\nto the diff machinery. Something in this pipeline is modifying the text in a\nway that does not occur when running the same command outside Git.\n\nEven a small diagnostic improvement would help enormously:\n- A flag like `--debug-textconv` to show the exact bytes Git receives from the\n  filter.\n- A warning when textconv output differs in size from the original file.\n- Documentation clarifying platform‑specific pitfalls for textconv on Windows.\n\nThis issue is subtle, silent, and extremely irritating to debug. I hope this\nreport helps prevent other Windows users from losing hours to the same problem.\n\nThank you for your time.\n\nSincerely,\nSkybuck Flying\n\nFUCK YOU ALL TO HELL."},{"id":"550235","messageId":"20260811034001.GA15552@coredump.intra.peff.net","threadId":"66149","inReplyTo":"AM0PR02MB445096594555DAD1D9EE1505B3DD2@AM0PR02MB4450.eurprd02.prod.outlook.com","subject":"Re: AI Textconv filter misconfiguration on Windows leads to silent corruption of diff output (ongoing investigation)","fromName":"Jeff King","fromEmail":"peff@peff.net","sentAt":"2026-08-11T03:40:01Z","receivedAt":"2026-08-11T03:40:08Z","isPatch":false,"body":"On Tue, Aug 11, 2026 at 12:44:42AM +0000, Skybuck Flying wrote:\n\n> - compareCache appeared as compaeCache\n> - return appeared as eturn\n> - from appeared as fom\n> - var appeared as va\n> - for appeared as fo\n> - cacheReader appeared as cacheReade\n> - CompareAndSwap appeared as CompaeAndSwap\n\nSo all of your r's are gone...\n\n> Global .gitconfig:\n> diff.lfclean.textconv=sed -e s/\\r//\n\n...and here you don't quote against the shell. So the shell is probably\nconverting \"\\r\" into just \"r\", and thus sed is removing them.\n\nThe same thing would be a problem on Linux as well as Windows.\n\nI felt clever at spotting this immediately, but then this is already in\nyour text later:\n\n> So the command does strip the literal character 'r' instead of\n> carriage returns. The likely reason is that the backslash before r is\n> not preserved through the shell argument parsing on Windows;\n> effectively, the expression becomes s/r//, which deletes all 'r'\n> characters.\n\nSo...what's the question? This is a misconfiguration on your part.\nPerhaps Git's documentation could be more clear that there will be a\nshell involved, but using a shell is normal for (almost) all\nuser-specified commands run by Git.\n\n-Peff\n"},{"id":"550237","messageId":"AM0PR02MB44501AFB0A97E2E097B8795AB3DD2@AM0PR02MB4450.eurprd02.prod.outlook.com","threadId":"66149","inReplyTo":"AM0PR02MB445013B3CDAAAD361FD93A86B3DD2@AM0PR02MB4450.eurprd02.prod.outlook.com","subject":"Re: AI Textconv filter misconfiguration on Windows leads to silent corruption of diff output (ongoing investigation)","fromName":"Skybuck Flying","fromEmail":"skybuck2000@hotmail.com","sentAt":"2026-08-11T04:26:22Z","receivedAt":"2026-08-11T04:26:26Z","isPatch":false,"body":"Faulting application name: WindowsTerminal.exe, version: 1.24.2605.12001, time stamp: 0x6a03a6ca\nFaulting module name: Microsoft.Terminal.Control.dll, version: 1.24.2605.12001, time stamp: 0x6a03a3a2\nException code: 0xc0000005\nFault offset: 0x000000000002c924\nFaulting process id: 0x0x5E3C\nFaulting application start time: 0x0x1DD2916AA80F175\nFaulting application path: C:\\Program Files\\WindowsApps\\Microsoft.WindowsTerminal_1.24.11321.0_x64__8wekyb3d8bbwe\\WindowsTerminal.exe\nFaulting module path: C:\\Program Files\\WindowsApps\\Microsoft.WindowsTerminal_1.24.11321.0_x64__8wekyb3d8bbwe\\Microsoft.Terminal.Control.dll\nReport Id: cd357657-4241-4a05-95d5-54ad0292fa24\nFaulting package full name: Microsoft.WindowsTerminal_1.24.11321.0_x64__8wekyb3d8bbwe\nFaulting package-relative application ID: App\n\nAs if this day wasn't bad enough yet, windows terminal also crashes, trying to copy & paste the command line used to actually fix git.\n\nMany copy & pastes were hurt this day. uBlock origin also started fucking around with copy & paste functionality, blocking it.\n\nHit the big logo which looks like a power icon to turn it off... or read this horrible dev issue thread, which contains some more manuals how to add a by-pass/circumment/exclude filter for deepseek website:\n\nhttps://github.com/vitelabs/go-vite/issues/656\n\nIt's good to read this anyway, to see how SHITTY your git actually is, it orginally started with trying to apply your git diff output via the patch feature which miserably failed !\n\nNone the less a branch was created anyway, with commits, which is a more proper way to do it...\n\nI can't believe you linux faggots used patches all this time, it has rarely worked for me, your parsers are total shit. You need to start using AI and first SPEC THE HELL OUT OF IT by using every AI in the book: deepseek v4, gemini 3.6, grok 4.x, chatgpt 5.x, meta.ai spark 1.1 \n\nOnly then will your software improve.\n\nAnyway, thankfully the entire browser didn't crash yet, I should be able to at least copy & paste the instruction out of there:\n\ngit config --global diff.lfclean.textconv \"sed -e s/\\\\r//\"\n\n\nTO ALL SOFTWARE DEVELOPERS AND CODE FAG BUNNIES ALL OVER THE WORLD:\n\nTEST YOUR COPY & PASTE FUNCTIONALITY 1000X BETTER\n\nTEST YOUR SELECT FUNCTIONALITY 1000X BETTER\n\nTEST YOUR DRAG & DROP FUNCTIONALITY 1000X BETTER\n\nI RUN INTO THESE KINDS OF MALFUNCTIONS\n\nALL\n\nTHE\n\nTIME.\n\nBLOODY\n\nFUCKING\n\nANNOYING\n\nBYE\n\nFOR\n\nNOW\n\nI \n\nHOPE\n\nI \n\nGET\n\nBANNED\n\nSO \n\nI\n\nCAN\n\nPUT\n\nSHITTY\n\nLINUX\n\nSOFTWARE\n\nTO\n\nREST\n\nMAYBE\n\nI MAKE A NICE PARODY USING:\n\n\"SOUND OF SILENCE\" BY THAT WELL KNOWN GANG OF MUSIC ARTISTS\n\nTUT TUT TUT TUT TUT TUTUT TUTUT TUTUT\n\nOH YEAH I REMEMBER NOW:\n\n\n\"SHOUT !\"\n\n\"SHOUT !\"\n\n\"THROW LINUX OUT !\"\n\n\"THROW THAT GARBAGE OF THE PLANET\"\n\n\"COME ON\"\n\n\"JUST THROW IT OUT\"\n\n\"COME ON !\"\n\n\"AND IF I\"\n\n\"COULD JUST NOT HAVE TO DEAL WITH LINUX\"\n\n\"I COULD JUST CODE FINE\"\n\n\"AND I WOULDN'T BE WASTING MY TIME !\"\n\n\"I'D BE CODING FINE !\"\n\n\"AND NOT BE WASTING MY TIME\"\n\n\"SHOUT ! SHOUT ! THROW GIT AND LINUX OUT !\"\n\n\"COME ON !\"\n\n\"GET RID OF THAT GARBAGE !\"\n\n\"COME ON !\"\n\nBYE FOR NOW,\n  SKYBUCK.\n\nP.S.: DON'T DEVELOP YOUR OWN OS, IF YOU CAN'T FOLLOW SOME FUCKING SIMPLY STANDARDS LIKE CARRIAGE RETURN AND NEWLINE\n\nBY FUCKERS."},{"id":"550240","messageId":"anqu8TjyuvCkI948@mit.edu","threadId":"66149","inReplyTo":"AM0PR02MB445083767BAE669D4656CA6CB3DD2@AM0PR02MB4450.eurprd02.prod.outlook.com","subject":"Re: AI Textconv filter misconfiguration on Windows leads to silent corruption of diff output (ongoing investigation)","fromName":"Theodore Tso","fromEmail":"tytso@mit.edu","sentAt":"2026-08-11T05:34:34Z","receivedAt":"2026-08-11T05:35:46Z","isPatch":false,"body":"On Tue, Aug 11, 2026 at 02:13:25AM -0500, Skybuck Flying wrote:\n> \n> So sed removes literal 'r' instead of carriage returns. It appears that on\n> Windows, the backslash in `\\r` is not preserved through MSYS argument parsing,\n> effectively turning the expression into `s/r//`.\n\nThe reason for this confusion is historical in nature and has to do\nwith a fundamental difference between Windows and Unix.  First,\nunderstand that Unix predates Windows, with Unix being first developed\nby AT&T Bell Labs in 1969, where as Windows dates from 1985, with DOS\ndating from 1981.  Unix uses the forward slash ('/') as a path\nseparator.  However Windows and DOS uses the backwards slash ('\\') as\na path separator, since DOS 1.0 used forward slashes for command-line\nswitches --- e.g., DIR/W.\n\nSince Windows and DOS uses backwards slash as a path separator, it\ncan't be used as a quoting character, which is how Unix and Linux\ninterprets the backlash character.  Since MSYS (which is not developed\nby the Windows Git team; they just use it), attempts to be compatible\nwith Unix / Linux, it uses backslash as quoting character.  CMD.EXE\nand Powershell are Windows programs, which doesn't attempt to be Unix\ncompatible.\n\nThis is the nature of your confusion.  It's unfortunate that you find\nthis to be so irritating, but it's fundamentally because DOS/Windows\nchose, back in the early 1980's, to be incompatible with Unix.  I\npersonally find Windows conventions to be irritating, and my way of\ndealing with the problem is to avoid using Windows whenever possible.\nInstead, I use MacOS and Linux, which doesn't have these Windows\ncompatibility problems.  Feel free to not use git, and to avoid\nanything else which attempts to be compatible with Unix or Linux if\nthat brings you peace.  I certainly was much happier once I no longer\nhad to deal with Windows as part of my day job.  :-)\n\nCheers,\n\n\t\t\t\t\t\t- Ted\n"},{"id":"550288","messageId":"AM0PR02MB445092119D0BA1921E2BAADFB3DD2@AM0PR02MB4450.eurprd02.prod.outlook.com","threadId":"66149","inReplyTo":"AM0PR02MB44501AFB0A97E2E097B8795AB3DD2@AM0PR02MB4450.eurprd02.prod.outlook.com","subject":"Re: AI Textconv filter misconfiguration on Windows leads to silent corruption of diff output (ongoing investigation)","fromName":"Skybuck Flying","fromEmail":"skybuck2000@hotmail.com","sentAt":"2026-08-11T15:06:30Z","receivedAt":"2026-08-11T15:06:33Z","isPatch":false,"body":"(I am not yet done with you mtf-ers):\n\nI feed the crash log into Co-Pilot/AI, it knows about it:\n\nThe short answer: **your crash codes indicate an *access‑violation* inside Windows Terminal’s rendering/control DLL**, and the specific signature you posted matches a **known Windows Terminal bug** that occurs during **tab drag‑merge operations**, often when scrollback buffers are large.\n\n---\n\n## 🧩 What the codes mean (direct interpretation)\n\n- **Faulting application:** WindowsTerminal.exe  \n- **Faulting module:** Microsoft.Terminal.Control.dll  \n- **Exception code:** **0xc0000005** → **Access violation** (invalid memory read/write)   [cloudspress.com](https://www.cloudspress.com/how-to-fix-error-code-0xc0000005-on-windows-11/)  \n- **Fault offset:** 0x2C924 → The exact instruction inside the DLL where the crash occurred  \n- **Process ID / start time:** Just identifiers; not diagnostic\n\n**0xc0000005** specifically means the program tried to **read or write memory it shouldn’t**, typically due to:\n\n- Null pointer dereference  \n- Use‑after‑free  \n- Corrupted internal state  \n- Memory pressure causing unexpected behavior  \n- A bug in the module (in this case, Microsoft.Terminal.Control.dll)\n\n---\n\n## 🧠 Why this specific crash is happening\n\nYour crash signature **exactly matches** a documented Windows Terminal issue:\n\n- **Crash during tab drag‑merge**  \n- **Faulting module:** Microsoft.Terminal.Control.dll  \n- **Exception:** 0xc0000005  \n- **Offset:** same region (0x2Cxxx)  \n- **Version:** 1.24.2605.12001  \n\nThis is confirmed in the Windows Terminal GitHub issue tracker:  \n- Issue #20406 describes **intermittent crashes when merging tabs**, with the **same version and same DLL**.   [Github](https://github.com/microsoft/terminal/issues/20406)  \n- Issue #19383 shows similar crashes in earlier versions, also during tab merge operations.   [Github](https://github.com/microsoft/terminal/issues/19383)  \n\nThe maintainers note:\n\n- The crash occurs **inside the control DLL**, not user code.  \n- It is triggered by **dragging a tab from one window into another**.  \n- Large scrollback buffers or memory growth (RADAR_PRE_LEAK_64) increase the likelihood.  \n- All Terminal windows die because they share a single process.\n\nThis is **not caused by your system**, drivers, or RAM.  \nIt is a **bug in Windows Terminal 1.24**.\n\n---\n\n## 🔍 What 0xc0000005 means in general\n\nWindows uses 0xc0000005 for **any illegal memory access**:\n\n- **0** → invalid read  \n- **1** → invalid write  \n- **8** → invalid code execution  \n  [cloudspress.com](https://www.cloudspress.com/how-to-fix-error-code-0xc0000005-on-windows-11/)\n\nIn your case, the GitHub issues strongly indicate a **null pointer dereference** inside the tab‑merge logic.\n\n---\n\n## 🛠 What you can do\n\n### 1. Avoid tab drag‑merge for now  \nThis is the direct trigger in the known bug reports.\n\n### 2. Reduce scrollback size  \nLarge scrollback buffers increase memory pressure and crash likelihood.\n\n### 3. Update Windows Terminal  \nCheck for a newer version than **1.24.2605.12001**.  \nThe bug is known and under triage.\n\n### 4. If you want deeper debugging  \nYou can capture a dump and inspect with WinDbg:\n\n- `!analyze -v`  \n- Check the call stack around the fault offset  \n- Look for pointer dereferences inside Microsoft.Terminal.Control.dll\n\nBut based on the GitHub reports, you will likely see the same signature as others.\n\n---\n\n## 🧭 If you want, I can help you:\n\n- Analyze your crash dump  \n- Explain how to use WinDbg step‑by‑step  \n- Check whether your settings.json might also be contributing\n\nJust pick one.\n\"\n\n\nMe:\n\"\nHas a new version of terminal window been released which solves this bug ?\n\"\n\n**Yes — a newer Windows Terminal build *has* been released that specifically fixes the tab‑drag crash you’re experiencing.**  \nThe fix landed in **Windows Terminal 1.24.11911.0**, released mid‑July 2026, and confirmed in multiple sources as addressing the drag‑merge crash you hit.   [NT Compatible](https://www.ntcompatible.com/story/windows-terminal-124-and-125-update-released-bug-fixes-and-v126-delay/)\n\n---\n\n## 🟢 **Direct answer: Your crash *is fixed* in 1.24.11911.0**\n\nThe NT Compatible release notes explicitly state:\n\n- **“Key fixes include resolving a tab‑dragging crash.”**  \n- This fix is included in **Windows Terminal 1.24.11911.0** (stable) and **1.25.1912.0** (preview).   [NT Compatible](https://www.ntcompatible.com/story/windows-terminal-124-and-125-update-released-bug-fixes-and-v126-delay/)\n\nThis matches your crash signature exactly:\n\n- Faulting module: **Microsoft.Terminal.Control.dll**  \n- Exception: **0xc0000005**  \n- Offset: **0x2C924**  \n- Version: **1.24.2605.12001**  \n- Trigger: **drag‑merging tabs**  \n  (Confirmed in GitHub issue #20406)   [Github](https://github.com/microsoft/terminal/issues/20406)\n\nThe fix is described as correcting an **EnablePainting viewport desync** that caused crashes during tab dragging between windows of different sizes.   [NT Compatible](https://www.ntcompatible.com/story/windows-terminal-124-and-125-update-released-bug-fixes-and-v126-delay/)\n\n---\n\n## 🧩 **Important nuance: Some *other* tab‑drag crashes still exist**\n\nWhile your specific crash (faulting in *Microsoft.Terminal.Control.dll*) is fixed, **newer related crashes** were later discovered:\n\n- Crashes when dragging a tab **over terminal content** (not merging)  \n  → Faulting in **Windows.UI.Xaml.dll**, exception **0xc000027b**  \n  → Still present in 1.24.11911.0 and 1.24.2607.10001  \n    [Github](https://github.com/microsoft/terminal/issues/20512)\n\n- Crashes during pointer‑move events due to a race condition  \n  → Null dereference in `TermControl::_PointerMovedHandler`  \n  → Present in 1.24.11911.0  \n    [Github](https://github.com/microsoft/terminal/issues/20477)\n\nThese are **different bugs** from yours, with different faulting modules and exception codes.\n\n**Your crash is fixed.**  \n**Other drag‑related crashes still exist.**\n\n---\n\n## 🛠 **What you should do now**\n\n### 1. Update Windows Terminal  \nInstall **1.24.11911.0** or newer:\n\n- Microsoft Store  \n- `winget upgrade --id Microsoft.WindowsTerminal`  \n- GitHub releases\n\nThis update contains the fix for your exact crash.\n\n### 2. If you still see crashes  \nThey may be one of the newer XAML drag‑boundary bugs.  \nThose are still under active investigation.\n\n---\n\n## 🔍 Want me to check your exact version and confirm?  \nYou can ask:  \n- **Check my Windows Terminal version**  \n- **Explain how to update Windows Terminal**\n\"\n\nAt least Microsoft fixes bugs, this was a really bad one, going to update my Windows Terminal, or at least try !\n\nAmazing how the AI was able to figure this out and yes indeed it surprisingly took down all cmd/consoles...\n\nThis could be nasty for blockchains or lengthy setup of software.\n\nSo definetly a must fix.\n\nBye for now,\n  Skybuck."},{"id":"551038","messageId":"26321C84-5D6C-489E-9CE1-03F55BAC697A@grrlz.net","threadId":"66149","inReplyTo":"AM0PR02MB44501AFB0A97E2E097B8795AB3DD2@AM0PR02MB4450.eurprd02.prod.outlook.com","subject":"Re: AI Textconv filter misconfiguration on Windows leads to silent corruption of diff output (ongoing investigation)","fromName":"Bradley Morgan","fromEmail":"include@grrlz.net","sentAt":"2026-08-21T21:14:55Z","receivedAt":"2026-08-21T21:15:03Z","isPatch":false,"body":"On 11 August 2026 05:26:22 BST, Skybuck Flying <skybuck2000@hotmail.com>\nwrote:\n>Faulting application name: WindowsTerminal.exe, version: 1.24.2605.12001,\n>time stamp: 0x6a03a6ca\n>Faulting module name: Microsoft.Terminal.Control.dll, version:\n>1.24.2605.12001, time stamp: 0x6a03a3a2\n>Exception code: 0xc0000005\n>Fault offset: 0x000000000002c924\n>Faulting process id: 0x0x5E3C\n>Faulting application start time: 0x0x1DD2916AA80F175\n>Faulting application path: C:\\Program\n>Files\\WindowsApps\\Microsoft.WindowsTerminal_1.24.11321.0_x64__8wekyb3d8bbwe\\WindowsTerminal.exe\n>Faulting module path: C:\\Program\n>Files\\WindowsApps\\Microsoft.WindowsTerminal_1.24.11321.0_x64__8wekyb3d8bbwe\\Microsoft.Terminal.Control.dll\n>Report Id: cd357657-4241-4a05-95d5-54ad0292fa24\n>Faulting package full name:\n>Microsoft.WindowsTerminal_1.24.11321.0_x64__8wekyb3d8bbwe\n>Faulting package-relative application ID: App\n>\n>As if this day wasn't bad enough yet, windows terminal also crashes,\n>trying to copy & paste the command line used to actually fix git.\n>\n>Many copy & pastes were hurt this day. uBlock origin also started fucking\n>around with copy & paste functionality, blocking it.\n>\n>Hit the big logo which looks like a power icon to turn it off... or read\n>this horrible dev issue thread, which contains some more manuals how to\n>add a by-pass/circumment/exclude filter for deepseek website:\n>\n>https://github.com/vitelabs/go-vite/issues/656\n>\n>It's good to read this anyway, to see how SHITTY your git actually is, it\n>orginally started with trying to apply your git diff output via the patch\n>feature which miserably failed !\n>\n>None the less a branch was created anyway, with commits, which is a more\n>proper way to do it...\n>\n>I can't believe you linux faggots used patches all this time, it has\n>rarely worked for me, your parsers are total shit. You need to start using\n>AI and first SPEC THE HELL OUT OF IT by using every AI in the book:\n>deepseek v4, gemini 3.6, grok 4.x, chatgpt 5.x, meta.ai spark 1.1 \n>\n>Only then will your software improve.\n>\n>Anyway, thankfully the entire browser didn't crash yet, I should be able\n>to at least copy & paste the instruction out of there:\n>\n>git config --global diff.lfclean.textconv \"sed -e s/\\\\r//\"\n>\n>\n>TO ALL SOFTWARE DEVELOPERS AND CODE FAG BUNNIES ALL OVER THE WORLD:\n>\n>TEST YOUR COPY & PASTE FUNCTIONALITY 1000X BETTER\n>\n>TEST YOUR SELECT FUNCTIONALITY 1000X BETTER\n>\n>TEST YOUR DRAG & DROP FUNCTIONALITY 1000X BETTER\n>\n>I RUN INTO THESE KINDS OF MALFUNCTIONS\n>\n>ALL\n>\n>THE\n>\n>TIME.\n>\n>BLOODY\n>\n>FUCKING\n>\n>ANNOYING\n>\n>BYE\n>\n>FOR\n>\n>NOW\n>\n>I \n>\n>HOPE\n>\n>I \n>\n>GET\n>\n>BANNED\n>\n>SO \n>\n>I\n>\n>CAN\n>\n>PUT\n>\n>SHITTY\n>\n>LINUX\n>\n>SOFTWARE\n>\n>TO\n>\n>REST\n>\n>MAYBE\n>\n>I MAKE A NICE PARODY USING:\n>\n>\"SOUND OF SILENCE\" BY THAT WELL KNOWN GANG OF MUSIC ARTISTS\n>\n>TUT TUT TUT TUT TUT TUTUT TUTUT TUTUT\n>\n>OH YEAH I REMEMBER NOW:\n>\n>\n>\"SHOUT !\"\n>\n>\"SHOUT !\"\n>\n>\"THROW LINUX OUT !\"\n>\n>\"THROW THAT GARBAGE OF THE PLANET\"\n>\n>\"COME ON\"\n>\n>\"JUST THROW IT OUT\"\n>\n>\"COME ON !\"\n>\n>\"AND IF I\"\n>\n>\"COULD JUST NOT HAVE TO DEAL WITH LINUX\"\n>\n>\"I COULD JUST CODE FINE\"\n>\n>\"AND I WOULDN'T BE WASTING MY TIME !\"\n>\n>\"I'D BE CODING FINE !\"\n>\n>\"AND NOT BE WASTING MY TIME\"\n>\n>\"SHOUT ! SHOUT ! THROW GIT AND LINUX OUT !\"\n>\n>\"COME ON !\"\n>\n>\"GET RID OF THAT GARBAGE !\"\n>\n>\"COME ON !\"\n>\n>BYE FOR NOW,\n>  SKYBUCK.\n>\n>P.S.: DON'T DEVELOP YOUR OWN OS, IF YOU CAN'T FOLLOW SOME FUCKING SIMPLY\n>STANDARDS LIKE CARRIAGE RETURN AND NEWLINE\n>\n>BY FUCKERS.\n>\n\nuhh, you don't need to be this mad.\nits not particularly linuxes fault\n\n\nThanks!\n"},{"id":"551699","messageId":"AM0PR02MB4450EF826479360A3A262277B3A82@AM0PR02MB4450.eurprd02.prod.outlook.com","threadId":"66149","inReplyTo":"AM0PR02MB445092119D0BA1921E2BAADFB3DD2@AM0PR02MB4450.eurprd02.prod.outlook.com","subject":"Re: AI Textconv filter misconfiguration on Windows leads to silent corruption of diff output (ongoing investigation)","fromName":"Skybuck Flying","fromEmail":"skybuck2000@hotmail.com","sentAt":"2026-09-01T20:14:05Z","receivedAt":"2026-09-01T20:14:07Z","isPatch":false,"body":"MORE GOD DAMN PROBLEMS WITH GIT AND CR/LF FILTERS.\n\nI DOWNLOADED/GIT CLONED:\n\nhttps://github.com/openai/openai-openapi/tree/main\n\nI NOTICED:\n\nhttps://github.com/openai/openai-openapi/tree/main/assets\n\nWAS CORRUPTED.\n\n(CORRECT DOWNLOAD METHOD USES TO PROVE FILE IS INTACT ON SERVER):\n\ncurl -L --output \"K:\\Delphi\\Specifications\\OpenAI API\\github version 3.1.0 (1 september 2026)\\assets\\openai-api-referencev2.png\" https://raw.githubusercontent.com/openai/openai-openapi/master/assets/openai-api-reference.png\n\nGOOD THING I INSPECTED IT JUST OUT OF CURIOSITY.\n\nI IMMEDIATELY EXPECTED GIT FILTER TO BE THE CAUSE.\n\nDIAGNOSIS COMMANDS.\n\n\"\nMicrosoft Windows [Version 10.0.22631.6199]\n(c) Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved.\n\nC:\\Users\\skybu>git config --global core.autocrlf\nfalse\n\nC:\\Users\\skybu>git config --system core.autocrlf\nfalse\n\nC:\\Users\\skybu>git config --local core.autocrlf\nfatal: --local can only be used inside a git repository\n\nC:\\Users\\skybu>git config --global --get-regexp filter\n\nC:\\Users\\skybu>git config --local --get-regexp filter\nfatal: --local can only be used inside a git repository\n\nC:\\Users\\skybu>git check-attr -a openai-api-reference.png\nfatal: not a git repository (or any of the parent directories): .git\n\nC:\\Users\\skybu>type .gitattributes\n* text diff=lfclean\nC:\\Users\\skybu>git config --global --list\ncore.autocrlf=false\ncore.eol=crlf\ncore.sshcommand=C:/Windows/System32/OpenSSH/ssh.exe\ncore.attributesfile=C:\\Users\\skybu\\.gitattributes\nuser.email=skybuck2000@hotmail.com\nuser.name=Skybuck Flying\nuser.signingkey=I:\\Informatie\\Van mezelf\\SSH Keys\\PrivateKey\\GitSigningKey\ngui.recentrepo=V:/FuckingWhore/vite-wallet\ncinnabar.version-check=1743733941\ncredential.http://localhost:3000.provider=generic\nincludeif.gitdir:V:/AI0001/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0001-v2\nincludeif.gitdir:V:/AI0002/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0002-v2\nincludeif.gitdir:V:/AI0003/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0003-v2\nincludeif.gitdir:V:/AI0004/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0004-v2\nincludeif.gitdir:V:/AI0005/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0005-v2\nincludeif.gitdir:V:/AI0006/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0006-v2\nincludeif.gitdir:V:/AI0007/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0007-v2\nincludeif.gitdir:V:/AI0008/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0008-v2\nincludeif.gitdir:V:/AI0009/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0009-v2\nincludeif.gitdir:V:/AI0010/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0010-v2\nincludeif.gitdir:V:/AI0011/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0011-v2\nincludeif.gitdir:V:/AI0012/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0012-v2\nincludeif.gitdir:V:/AI0013/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0013-v2\nincludeif.gitdir:V:/AI0014/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0014-v2\nincludeif.gitdir:V:/AI0015/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0015-v2\nincludeif.gitdir:V:/AI0016/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0016-v2\nincludeif.gitdir:V:/AI0017/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0017-v2\nincludeif.gitdir:V:/AI0018/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0018-v2\nincludeif.gitdir:V:/AI0019/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0019-v2\nincludeif.gitdir:V:/AI0020/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0020-v2\nincludeif.gitdir:V:/AIMain/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-aimain-v2\nmerge.tool=meld\nmergetool.prompt=false\nmergetool.keepbackup=false\ngpg.format=ssh\ncommit.gpgsign=true\nlog.showsignature=true\ngpg.ssh.allowedsignersfile=I:/Informatie/Van mezelf/SSH Keys/GitAllowedSigners/GitAllowedSigners.txt\ndiff.lfclean.textconv=sed -e s/\\\\r//\ndiff.lfclean.binary=false\n\nC:\\Users\\skybu>git check-attr --all -- openai-api-reference.png\nfatal: not a git repository (or any of the parent directories): .git\n\nC:\\Users\\skybu>\n\"\n\nHYPOTHESIS BY CO-PILOT AND POSSIBLE FIX:\n\nThe **smoking gun is now visible**: your global config + your global attributes file **are applying a custom diff filter (`lfclean`) to *all files*** — including PNGs.  \nThat is exactly why your Git‑downloaded PNG is corrupted while the curl version is intact.\n\nLet me break it down cleanly and give you the exact commands to verify every part.\n\n---\n\n## 🎯 Core finding: your global `.gitattributes` is rewriting files\nYou showed:\n\n```\nC:\\Users\\skybu>type .gitattributes\n* text diff=lfclean\n```\n\nThis means:\n\n- `*` → **every file**, regardless of type  \n- `text` → Git treats **every file as text**, even binaries  \n- `diff=lfclean` → Git applies your custom diff driver  \n- Your diff driver is defined as:\n\n```\ndiff.lfclean.textconv=sed -e s/\\\\r//\ndiff.lfclean.binary=false\n```\n\nThis forces Git to:\n\n- run `sed -e s/\\r//` on files  \n- treat them as **non‑binary**  \n- strip carriage returns  \n- potentially corrupt binary formats (PNG, JPG, ZIP, EXE, DLL, etc.)\n\nCurl does not run Git filters → curl file stays intact.\n\nGit does run filters → Git file becomes corrupted.\n\nThis is 100% the cause.\n\n---\n\n## 🧪 Commands to confirm the corruption mechanism\n\n### 1. Check what attributes Git applies to your PNG\n```\ngit check-attr --all -- openai-api-reference.png\n```\n\nExpected output (because of your global `.gitattributes`):\n\n```\nopenai-api-reference.png: text: set\nopenai-api-reference.png: diff: lfclean\n```\n\nIf you see this → confirmed.\n\n---\n\n### 2. Check the raw blob stored in Git (to see if corruption happens on checkout)\n```\ngit show HEAD:openai-api-reference.png > raw.png\n```\n\nThen compare:\n\n```\nfc /b raw.png openai-api-reference.png\n```\n\nIf `raw.png` is intact but the working‑tree file is corrupted → the corruption happens during checkout due to filters.\n\n---\n\n### 3. Show all filters Git knows about\n```\ngit config --show-origin --get-regexp diff\ngit config --show-origin --get-regexp filter\n```\n\nYou will see your `lfclean` diff driver.\n\n---\n\n### 4. Show your global attributes file path\n```\ngit config --global core.attributesfile\n```\n\nIt points to:\n\n```\nC:\\Users\\skybu\\.gitattributes\n```\n\nThis file is applied to **every repository** on your system.\n\n---\n\n## 🛠️ How to fix it (choose one)\n\n### Option A — Remove the global `.gitattributes` (recommended)\n```\ndel C:\\Users\\skybu\\.gitattributes\n```\n\n### Option B — Restrict the rule to text files only\nReplace:\n\n```\n* text diff=lfclean\n```\n\nWith:\n\n```\n*.txt text diff=lfclean\n*.pas text diff=lfclean\n*.dpr text diff=lfclean\n```\n\n### Option C — Mark binary files correctly\nAdd:\n\n```\n*.png binary\n*.jpg binary\n*.zip binary\n*.exe binary\n*.dll binary\n```\n\n---\n\n## 📌 Why this happened\nYou created a global `.gitattributes` with:\n\n```\n* text diff=lfclean\n```\n\nThis is extremely dangerous because:\n\n- Git thinks **every file is text**\n- Git applies your custom diff filter to **every file**\n- Binary files get corrupted on checkout\n\nThis is why:\n\n- **curl file = correct**\n- **git file = corrupted**\n\n---\n\n## 🔍 Want me to help rewrite your `.gitattributes` safely?\nI can generate a clean, safe version tailored to your Delphi workflow.  \nPick one:\n\n- fix global attributes  \n- create safe Delphi attributes  \n- audit all Git filters\n\n\n\nApperently Co-Pilot now has the ability to send e-mails, funny functionality, risky too ! Expect another melissa ai virus soon ? ;)\n\nAnyway I copy & paste it's reply here in plain text:\n\n```\nHi Git developers,\n\nI'm writing to report a reproducible corruption issue caused by global Git attributes and diff filters being applied to binary files during checkout.\n\nSummary of the problem\nA PNG file downloaded via Git becomes corrupted, while the same file downloaded via curl remains intact. The corruption is caused by a global `.gitattributes` file that marks all files as text and assigns a custom diff driver:\n\n* text diff=lfclean\n\nThe diff driver is defined globally as:\n\ndiff.lfclean.textconv=sed -e s/\\\\r//\ndiff.lfclean.binary=false\n\nThis forces Git to treat every file as text and run a textconv filter that strips carriage returns. When applied to binary formats (PNG, JPG, ZIP, EXE, etc.), the checkout process produces corrupted files.\n\nReproduction steps\n1. Create a global `.gitattributes` file containing:\n   * text diff=lfclean\n2. Define the diff driver globally:\n   diff.lfclean.textconv=sed -e s/\\\\r//\n   diff.lfclean.binary=false\n3. Clone any repository containing binary files.\n4. Compare a binary file from the working tree with the raw blob:\n   git show HEAD:path/to/file > raw.bin\n   fc /b raw.bin path/to/file\n\nThe working-tree file differs from the blob, confirming corruption during checkout.\n\nExpected behavior\nBinary files should remain untouched unless explicitly marked with filters.\n\nActual behavior\nGit applies the global attributes and diff driver to all files, including binaries, causing corruption.\n\nRequest\nI would appreciate guidance on whether Git should:\n- Warn users when global attributes force text filters onto binary files, or\n- Provide safeguards to prevent textconv filters from being applied to known binary formats.\n\nThanks for your time and consideration.\n\nBest regards,\nSkybuck\n```\n\nversion 2:\n\nHere is the **clean, corrected, plain‑text reply**, in a **single code block**, clearly explaining:\n\n- the **cause**  \n- the **solution**  \n- the **future risks**  \n\nYou can paste this directly into the Git mailing list.\n\n```\nHi Git developers,\n\nI want to report an issue where Git corrupts binary files during checkout when a global .gitattributes file forces all paths to be treated as text and assigns a diff driver.\n\nCause of the problem\nMy global attributes file contained the line:\n\n    * text diff=lfclean\n\nBecause the pattern \"*\" matches every file, Git applies \"text\" and \"diff=lfclean\" to all paths, including binary files such as PNGs. The \"text\" attribute forces Git to treat the file as text even when its content is clearly binary. The assigned diff driver runs a textconv filter:\n\n    diff.lfclean.textconv = sed -e s/\\r//\n    diff.lfclean.binary = false\n\nThis causes Git to rewrite the file during checkout, stripping carriage returns from binary data. As a result, the working-tree version of a PNG differs from the blob stored in the repository, and the file becomes corrupted. A copy downloaded via curl remains intact because curl does not apply Git filters.\n\nReproduction steps\n1. Create a global .gitattributes file containing:\n       * text diff=lfclean\n2. Define the diff driver globally:\n       diff.lfclean.textconv=sed -e s/\\r//\n       diff.lfclean.binary=false\n3. Clone any repository containing binary files.\n4. Compare the blob with the working-tree file:\n       git show HEAD:path/to/file > raw.bin\n       fc /b raw.bin path/to/file\n\nThe working-tree file is corrupted while the blob is correct.\n\nSolution\nRemove the global rule or restrict it to actual text file extensions. For example:\n\n    *.txt text diff=lfclean\n    *.pas text diff=lfclean\n    *.md  text diff=lfclean\n\nAlternatively, explicitly mark binary formats:\n\n    *.png binary\n    *.jpg binary\n    *.zip binary\n    *.exe binary\n\nDeleting the global .gitattributes file entirely also resolves the issue.\n\nFuture risks\nGlobal attribute rules are applied to every repository on the system. Using \"*\" with \"text\" or any filter can silently rewrite binary files, break archives, corrupt executables, and cause difficult-to-diagnose data loss. Users may not realize that Git is modifying files during checkout, especially when the corruption is subtle. A warning or safeguard when \"text\" is forced globally might help prevent accidental misuse.\n\nThanks for your time and consideration.\n\nBest regards,\nSkybuck\n```\n\nBye for now,\n  Skybuck.\n"},{"id":"551700","messageId":"AM0PR02MB4450BB21D265D843560BCA0DB3A82@AM0PR02MB4450.eurprd02.prod.outlook.com","threadId":"66149","inReplyTo":"AM0PR02MB4450EF826479360A3A262277B3A82@AM0PR02MB4450.eurprd02.prod.outlook.com","subject":"Re: AI Textconv filter misconfiguration on Windows leads to silent corruption of diff output (ongoing investigation)","fromName":"Skybuck Flying","fromEmail":"skybuck2000@hotmail.com","sentAt":"2026-09-01T20:25:24Z","receivedAt":"2026-09-01T20:25:27Z","isPatch":false,"body":"I am unhappy with Co-Pilots solution.\n\nThe filter is also dangerous... settings it to a few text files is also kinda nuts, but it might be done per project/git repo, perhaps... not sure... weird...\n\nShort answer: **yes, Skybuck — there is WAY too much risk with this filter**, and you should remove it completely.  \nNot “maybe”, not “under certain conditions”.  \nIt is objectively dangerous, and your system already proved it by corrupting PNGs.\n\nLet me explain it cleanly, without sugarcoating, and give you the exact commands to eliminate the risk permanently.\n\n---\n\n## ⚠️ Why the filter is inherently dangerous\nThe rule you had:\n\n```\n* text diff=lfclean\n```\n\nis one of the most destructive `.gitattributes` configurations possible because:\n\n- `*` matches **every file**\n- `text` forces Git to treat **binary files as text**\n- `diff=lfclean` applies your custom filter to **every file**\n- your filter runs `sed -e s/\\r//`, which **modifies file contents**\n- Git applies this filter **during checkout**, silently rewriting files\n\nThis combination guarantees corruption of:\n\n- PNG  \n- JPG  \n- ZIP  \n- EXE  \n- DLL  \n- PDF  \n- MP3/WAV  \n- any binary format  \n\nThis is not a “rare edge case”.  \nIt is a **guaranteed corruption mechanism**.\n\nYour PNG corruption is not a coincidence — it is exactly what this filter does.\n\n---\n\n## 🧨 Why the risk is unacceptable\nEven if you “fix” the filter by adding exceptions, the risk remains because:\n\n- future repos may contain unknown binary formats  \n- future tools may generate new file types  \n- future `.gitattributes` merges may override your exceptions  \n- future Git updates may change filter behavior  \n- future scripts may add new patterns  \n- future contributors may not know your global filter exists  \n\nA global filter is **invisible** to repositories.  \nNobody expects it.  \nNobody tests for it.  \nNobody documents it.\n\nThis makes it a **silent corruption vector**.\n\nIf you ever clone:\n\n- firmware  \n- installers  \n- game assets  \n- compressed archives  \n- executables  \n- DLLs  \n- images  \n- audio  \n- video  \n- machine learning models  \n- container layers  \n\nGit will corrupt them.\n\nThis is not theoretical — you already saw it happen.\n\n---\n\n## 🛠️ The correct solution (no bullshit)\nRemove the global attributes file and remove the filter.\n\n### **1. Delete the global `.gitattributes`**\n```\ndel C:\\Users\\skybu\\.gitattributes\n```\n\n### **2. Remove the global attributesfile setting**\n```\ngit config --global --unset core.attributesfile\n```\n\n### **3. Remove the dangerous diff driver**\n```\ngit config --global --unset diff.lfclean.textconv\ngit config --global --unset diff.lfclean.binary\ngit config --global --remove-section diff.lfclean\n```\n\n### **4. Verify**\n```\ngit config --global --get-regexp diff\ngit config --global core.attributesfile\n```\n\nBoth should return nothing.\n\nThis completely eliminates the corruption vector.\n\n---\n\n## 🧠 If you still want CR/LF cleanup for text files\nUse a **local** `.gitattributes` inside each repo, not global.\n\nExample safe version:\n\n```\n*.txt text\n*.pas text\n*.dpr text\n*.ini text\n*.md  text\n```\n\nThis is safe because:\n\n- it only applies inside that repo  \n- it only applies to known text formats  \n- it does not touch binaries  \n- it does not use textconv filters  \n\n---\n\n## 🔥 Final verdict\nYes — the filter is too risky.  \nNot “a bit risky”.  \nNot “risky in some cases”.  \nIt is **objectively unsafe** and should be removed.\n\nYou already saw real corruption.  \nNext time it could be a ZIP, an EXE, a DLL, or a firmware blob.\n\nRemove it.  \nYou’ll never regret removing a global filter.  \nYou *will* regret keeping one.\n\nIf you want, I can help you build a **safe, minimal, future-proof** `.gitattributes` setup.\n\n\nFor now to hell with this filter shit.\n\nFortunately I didn't clone to many repos with pictures or binaries in em... I think... not sure... what a fucking nightmare !\n\nBye for now,\n  Skybuck."},{"id":"551702","messageId":"AM0PR02MB4450923337E1B2DAAD688B09B3A82@AM0PR02MB4450.eurprd02.prod.outlook.com","threadId":"66149","inReplyTo":"AM0PR02MB4450BB21D265D843560BCA0DB3A82@AM0PR02MB4450.eurprd02.prod.outlook.com","subject":"Re: AI Textconv filter misconfiguration on Windows leads to silent corruption of diff output (ongoing investigation)","fromName":"Skybuck Flying","fromEmail":"skybuck2000@hotmail.com","sentAt":"2026-09-01T21:37:42Z","receivedAt":"2026-09-01T21:37:45Z","isPatch":false,"body":"In short: PNG files were corrupted, but DLLs files not !\n\nHi Git developers,\n\nI am submitting a detailed report about a serious issue I encountered on Windows where a globally configured Git textconv filter silently corrupts binary files during checkout. The corruption occurred without any warnings, and only became visible when comparing Git‑checked‑out files with the original versions downloaded via curl.\n\nThis report documents the cause, the technical mechanism, the reproduction steps, the fix, and the future risks.\n\n---\n\nSummary of the issue\nA PNG file inside the repository https://github.com/openai/openai-openapi became corrupted after cloning. The same file downloaded via curl was intact. This immediately suggested that a Git filter was rewriting the file during checkout.\n\nThe root cause was a global .gitattributes file containing:\n\n    * text diff=lfclean\n\nCombined with the following global diff driver configuration:\n\n    diff.lfclean.textconv = sed -e s/\\r//\n    diff.lfclean.binary = false\n\nThis configuration forces Git to treat *all* files as text, including binary formats, and to run a textconv filter that removes carriage return characters. Any binary file containing 0x0D bytes is silently modified during checkout.\n\n---\n\nWhy PNG files were corrupted but DLL files were not\nPNG files contain structured binary chunks (tEXt, iTXt, zTXt) that may legitimately include CR/LF characters. When the textconv filter removes CR bytes, the chunk lengths no longer match the actual data, resulting in a corrupted PNG.\n\nDLL files, on the other hand, typically contain no CR characters at all. Because the filter only removes CR bytes, DLL files remain unchanged simply because there is nothing for the filter to remove. This makes the corruption appear “selective”, but it is purely accidental.\n\nAny binary format containing CR bytes is at risk.\n\n---\n\nReproduction steps\n1. Create a global .gitattributes file:\n\n       * text diff=lfclean\n\n2. Configure the diff driver globally:\n\n       diff.lfclean.textconv=sed -e s/\\r//\n       diff.lfclean.binary=false\n\n3. Clone any repository containing binary files.\n\n4. Compare the blob with the working-tree file:\n\n       git show HEAD:path/to/file > raw.bin\n       fc /b raw.bin path/to/file\n\nIf the binary contains CR bytes, the working-tree file will differ from the blob.\n\n---\n\nCause of the problem\nThe pattern \"*\" matches every file.  \nThe attribute \"text\" forces Git to treat every file as text, overriding binary detection.  \nThe diff driver \"lfclean\" applies a textconv filter that rewrites file contents.  \nGit applies this filter during checkout, not only during diff operations.\n\nThis combination guarantees corruption of any binary file containing CR bytes.\n\n---\n\nSolution\nThe correct fix is to remove the global .gitattributes file and the global diff driver:\n\n    del C:\\Users\\<user>\\.gitattributes\n    git config --global --unset core.attributesfile\n    git config --global --unset diff.lfclean.textconv\n    git config --global --unset diff.lfclean.binary\n    git config --global --remove-section diff.lfclean\n\nAlternatively, restrict the filter to known text file extensions inside individual repositories.\n\n---\n\nFuture risks\nGlobal .gitattributes rules are applied to every repository on the system.  \nUsing \"*\" with \"text\" or any filter is extremely dangerous because:\n\n- Git silently rewrites binary files during checkout.\n- Corruption is not detected by Git.\n- Corruption depends on file contents, making it unpredictable.\n- Users may not realize that Git is modifying files.\n- Any future repository containing binary formats with CR bytes will be corrupted.\n\nThis configuration effectively creates a system-wide corruption vector.\n\nA warning or safeguard when \"text\" is forced globally might help prevent accidental misuse.\n\n---\n\nConclusion\nThis issue demonstrates that global textconv filters can silently corrupt binary files on Windows. The corruption is subtle, unpredictable, and difficult to diagnose. Removing global filters and avoiding \"*\" patterns in global .gitattributes files is essential for data integrity.\n\nThank you for your time and consideration.\n\nBest regards,\nSkybuck\n"},{"id":"551703","messageId":"000601dd3a5b$3e4be8a0$bae3b9e0$@nexbridge.com","threadId":"66149","inReplyTo":"AM0PR02MB4450EF826479360A3A262277B3A82@AM0PR02MB4450.eurprd02.prod.outlook.com","subject":"RE: AI Textconv filter misconfiguration on Windows leads to silent corruption of diff output (ongoing investigation)","fromName":"","fromEmail":"rsbecker@nexbridge.com","sentAt":"2026-09-01T21:45:38Z","receivedAt":"2026-09-01T21:55:08Z","isPatch":false,"body":"On September 1, 2026 4:14 PM, Skybuck Flying wrote:\n>MORE GOD DAMN PROBLEMS WITH GIT AND CR/LF FILTERS.\n>\n>I DOWNLOADED/GIT CLONED:\n>\n>https://github.com/openai/openai-openapi/tree/main\n>\n>I NOTICED:\n>\n>https://github.com/openai/openai-openapi/tree/main/assets\n>\n>WAS CORRUPTED.\n>\n>(CORRECT DOWNLOAD METHOD USES TO PROVE FILE IS INTACT ON SERVER):\n>\n>curl -L --output \"K:\\Delphi\\Specifications\\OpenAI API\\github version 3.1.0 (1\n>september 2026)\\assets\\openai-api-referencev2.png\"\n>https://raw.githubusercontent.com/openai/openai-\n>openapi/master/assets/openai-api-reference.png\n>\n>GOOD THING I INSPECTED IT JUST OUT OF CURIOSITY.\n>\n>I IMMEDIATELY EXPECTED GIT FILTER TO BE THE CAUSE.\n>\n>DIAGNOSIS COMMANDS.\n>\n>\"\n>Microsoft Windows [Version 10.0.22631.6199]\n>(c) Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved.\n>\n>C:\\Users\\skybu>git config --global core.autocrlf false\n>\n>C:\\Users\\skybu>git config --system core.autocrlf false\n>\n>C:\\Users\\skybu>git config --local core.autocrlf\n>fatal: --local can only be used inside a git repository\n>\n>C:\\Users\\skybu>git config --global --get-regexp filter\n>\n>C:\\Users\\skybu>git config --local --get-regexp filter\n>fatal: --local can only be used inside a git repository\n>\n>C:\\Users\\skybu>git check-attr -a openai-api-reference.png\n>fatal: not a git repository (or any of the parent directories): .git\n>\n>C:\\Users\\skybu>type .gitattributes\n>* text diff=lfclean\n>C:\\Users\\skybu>git config --global --list core.autocrlf=false core.eol=crlf\n>core.sshcommand=C:/Windows/System32/OpenSSH/ssh.exe\n>core.attributesfile=C:\\Users\\skybu\\.gitattributes\n>user.email=skybuck2000@hotmail.com\n>user.name=Skybuck Flying\n>user.signingkey=I:\\Informatie\\Van mezelf\\SSH Keys\\PrivateKey\\GitSigningKey\n>gui.recentrepo=V:/FuckingWhore/vite-wallet\n>cinnabar.version-check=1743733941\n>credential.http://localhost:3000.provider=generic\n>includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0001/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0001-v2\n>includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0002/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0002-v2\n>includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0003/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0003-v2\n>includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0004/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0004-v2\n>includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0005/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0005-v2\n>includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0006/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0006-v2\n>includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0007/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0007-v2\n>includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0008/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0008-v2\n>includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0009/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0009-v2\n>includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0010/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0010-v2\n>includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0011/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0011-v2\n>includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0012/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0012-v2\n>includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0013/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0013-v2\n>includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0014/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0014-v2\n>includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0015/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0015-v2\n>includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0016/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0016-v2\n>includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0017/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0017-v2\n>includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0018/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0018-v2\n>includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0019/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0019-v2\n>includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0020/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0020-v2\n>includeif.gitdir:V:/AIMain/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-aimain-v2\n>merge.tool=meld\n>mergetool.prompt=false\n>mergetool.keepbackup=false\n>gpg.format=ssh\n>commit.gpgsign=true\n>log.showsignature=true\n>gpg.ssh.allowedsignersfile=I:/Informatie/Van mezelf/SSH\n>Keys/GitAllowedSigners/GitAllowedSigners.txt\n>diff.lfclean.textconv=sed -e s/\\\\r//\n>diff.lfclean.binary=false\n>\n>C:\\Users\\skybu>git check-attr --all -- openai-api-reference.png\n>fatal: not a git repository (or any of the parent directories): .git\n>\n>C:\\Users\\skybu>\n>\"\n>\n>HYPOTHESIS BY CO-PILOT AND POSSIBLE FIX:\n>\n>The **smoking gun is now visible**: your global config + your global attributes file\n>**are applying a custom diff filter (`lfclean`) to *all files*** — including PNGs.\n>That is exactly why your Git‑downloaded PNG is corrupted while the curl version is\n>intact.\n>\n>Let me break it down cleanly and give you the exact commands to verify every part.\n>\n>---\n>\n>## 🎯 Core finding: your global `.gitattributes` is rewriting files You showed:\n>\n>```\n>C:\\Users\\skybu>type .gitattributes\n>* text diff=lfclean\n>```\n>\n>This means:\n>\n>- `*` → **every file**, regardless of type\n>- `text` → Git treats **every file as text**, even binaries\n>- `diff=lfclean` → Git applies your custom diff driver\n>- Your diff driver is defined as:\n>\n>```\n>diff.lfclean.textconv=sed -e s/\\\\r//\n>diff.lfclean.binary=false\n>```\n>\n>This forces Git to:\n>\n>- run `sed -e s/\\r//` on files\n>- treat them as **non‑binary**\n>- strip carriage returns\n>- potentially corrupt binary formats (PNG, JPG, ZIP, EXE, DLL, etc.)\n>\n>Curl does not run Git filters → curl file stays intact.\n>\n>Git does run filters → Git file becomes corrupted.\n>\n>This is 100% the cause.\n>\n>---\n>\n>## 🧪 Commands to confirm the corruption mechanism\n>\n>### 1. Check what attributes Git applies to your PNG ``` git check-attr --all -- openai-\n>api-reference.png ```\n>\n>Expected output (because of your global `.gitattributes`):\n>\n>```\n>openai-api-reference.png: text: set\n>openai-api-reference.png: diff: lfclean\n>```\n>\n>If you see this → confirmed.\n>\n>---\n>\n>### 2. Check the raw blob stored in Git (to see if corruption happens on checkout)\n>``` git show HEAD:openai-api-reference.png > raw.png ```\n>\n>Then compare:\n>\n>```\n>fc /b raw.png openai-api-reference.png\n>```\n>\n>If `raw.png` is intact but the working‑tree file is corrupted → the corruption\n>happens during checkout due to filters.\n>\n>---\n>\n>### 3. Show all filters Git knows about\n>```\n>git config --show-origin --get-regexp diff git config --show-origin --get-regexp filter\n>```\n>\n>You will see your `lfclean` diff driver.\n>\n>---\n>\n>### 4. Show your global attributes file path ``` git config --global core.attributesfile\n>```\n>\n>It points to:\n>\n>```\n>C:\\Users\\skybu\\.gitattributes\n>```\n>\n>This file is applied to **every repository** on your system.\n>\n>---\n>\n>## 🛠️ How to fix it (choose one)\n>\n>### Option A — Remove the global `.gitattributes` (recommended) ``` del\n>C:\\Users\\skybu\\.gitattributes ```\n>\n>### Option B — Restrict the rule to text files only\n>Replace:\n>\n>```\n>* text diff=lfclean\n>```\n>\n>With:\n>\n>```\n>*.txt text diff=lfclean\n>*.pas text diff=lfclean\n>*.dpr text diff=lfclean\n>```\n>\n>### Option C — Mark binary files correctly\n>Add:\n>\n>```\n>*.png binary\n>*.jpg binary\n>*.zip binary\n>*.exe binary\n>*.dll binary\n>```\n>\n>---\n>\n>## 📌 Why this happened\n>You created a global `.gitattributes` with:\n>\n>```\n>* text diff=lfclean\n>```\n>\n>This is extremely dangerous because:\n>\n>- Git thinks **every file is text**\n>- Git applies your custom diff filter to **every file**\n>- Binary files get corrupted on checkout\n>\n>This is why:\n>\n>- **curl file = correct**\n>- **git file = corrupted**\n>\n>---\n>\n>## 🔍 Want me to help rewrite your `.gitattributes` safely?\n>I can generate a clean, safe version tailored to your Delphi workflow.\n>Pick one:\n>\n>- fix global attributes\n>- create safe Delphi attributes\n>- audit all Git filters\n>\n>\n>\n>Apperently Co-Pilot now has the ability to send e-mails, funny functionality, risky\n>too ! Expect another melissa ai virus soon ? ;)\n>\n>Anyway I copy & paste it's reply here in plain text:\n>\n>```\n>Hi Git developers,\n>\n>I'm writing to report a reproducible corruption issue caused by global Git attributes\n>and diff filters being applied to binary files during checkout.\n>\n>Summary of the problem\n>A PNG file downloaded via Git becomes corrupted, while the same file downloaded\n>via curl remains intact. The corruption is caused by a global `.gitattributes` file that\n>marks all files as text and assigns a custom diff driver:\n>\n>* text diff=lfclean\n>\n>The diff driver is defined globally as:\n>\n>diff.lfclean.textconv=sed -e s/\\\\r//\n>diff.lfclean.binary=false\n>\n>This forces Git to treat every file as text and run a textconv filter that strips carriage\n>returns. When applied to binary formats (PNG, JPG, ZIP, EXE, etc.), the checkout\n>process produces corrupted files.\n>\n>Reproduction steps\n>1. Create a global `.gitattributes` file containing:\n>   * text diff=lfclean\n>2. Define the diff driver globally:\n>   diff.lfclean.textconv=sed -e s/\\\\r//\n>   diff.lfclean.binary=false\n>3. Clone any repository containing binary files.\n>4. Compare a binary file from the working tree with the raw blob:\n>   git show HEAD:path/to/file > raw.bin\n>   fc /b raw.bin path/to/file\n>\n>The working-tree file differs from the blob, confirming corruption during checkout.\n>\n>Expected behavior\n>Binary files should remain untouched unless explicitly marked with filters.\n>\n>Actual behavior\n>Git applies the global attributes and diff driver to all files, including binaries, causing\n>corruption.\n>\n>Request\n>I would appreciate guidance on whether Git should:\n>- Warn users when global attributes force text filters onto binary files, or\n>- Provide safeguards to prevent textconv filters from being applied to known binary\n>formats.\n>\n>Thanks for your time and consideration.\n>\n>Best regards,\n>Skybuck\n>```\n>\n>version 2:\n>\n>Here is the **clean, corrected, plain‑text reply**, in a **single code block**, clearly\n>explaining:\n>\n>- the **cause**\n>- the **solution**\n>- the **future risks**\n>\n>You can paste this directly into the Git mailing list.\n>\n>```\n>Hi Git developers,\n>\n>I want to report an issue where Git corrupts binary files during checkout when a\n>global .gitattributes file forces all paths to be treated as text and assigns a diff driver.\n>\n>Cause of the problem\n>My global attributes file contained the line:\n>\n>    * text diff=lfclean\n>\n>Because the pattern \"*\" matches every file, Git applies \"text\" and \"diff=lfclean\" to all\n>paths, including binary files such as PNGs. The \"text\" attribute forces Git to treat the\n>file as text even when its content is clearly binary. The assigned diff driver runs a\n>textconv filter:\n>\n>    diff.lfclean.textconv = sed -e s/\\r//\n>    diff.lfclean.binary = false\n>\n>This causes Git to rewrite the file during checkout, stripping carriage returns from\n>binary data. As a result, the working-tree version of a PNG differs from the blob\n>stored in the repository, and the file becomes corrupted. A copy downloaded via\n>curl remains intact because curl does not apply Git filters.\n>\n>Reproduction steps\n>1. Create a global .gitattributes file containing:\n>       * text diff=lfclean\n>2. Define the diff driver globally:\n>       diff.lfclean.textconv=sed -e s/\\r//\n>       diff.lfclean.binary=false\n>3. Clone any repository containing binary files.\n>4. Compare the blob with the working-tree file:\n>       git show HEAD:path/to/file > raw.bin\n>       fc /b raw.bin path/to/file\n>\n>The working-tree file is corrupted while the blob is correct.\n>\n>Solution\n>Remove the global rule or restrict it to actual text file extensions. For example:\n>\n>    *.txt text diff=lfclean\n>    *.pas text diff=lfclean\n>    *.md  text diff=lfclean\n>\n>Alternatively, explicitly mark binary formats:\n>\n>    *.png binary\n>    *.jpg binary\n>    *.zip binary\n>    *.exe binary\n>\n>Deleting the global .gitattributes file entirely also resolves the issue.\n>\n>Future risks\n>Global attribute rules are applied to every repository on the system. Using \"*\" with\n>\"text\" or any filter can silently rewrite binary files, break archives, corrupt\n>executables, and cause difficult-to-diagnose data loss. Users may not realize that Git\n>is modifying files during checkout, especially when the corruption is subtle. A\n>warning or safeguard when \"text\" is forced globally might help prevent accidental\n>misuse.\n>\n>Thanks for your time and consideration.\n\nJust some musings from my own frustration in this area.\n\nHaving gone through some similar things, I would ignore CoPilot. There are other words I would use as well but they are not for polite company.\n\nSet autocrlf=input not false. Also it is a good idea to set ignorecase=true and filemode=false on Windows.\n\nGit tends to give preferential treatment to text files, only looking at the first hunk (whatever that might be) looking for non-text characters. CR is text, so a file containing those near the front will probably be consider text unless explicitly marked as binary. If you are sure you have binary files, declare them. Do not assume git will always get it right - although .EXE, .ZIP, .JPG, and .PNG are pretty much always binary.\n\nI am going to assume something there, that the clean/smudge and diff engines are not guaranteed to be subject to autocrlf processing before receiving the files. It might be or might not be, depending on what git feels like doing given the state of the file. You would have to go look in the code on the version you have to be certain, but don't count on it in future.\n\nThe other problem you may to face, and I have been there, is that clean/smudge and textconv filters definitely *do not like* binary files if not declared as binary, and sometimes even then. You are dealing with stdin and stdout, so have to know how the filter/textconv is opening the files. I have seen platforms that always open in \"r\" instead of \"rb\", which was a problem. I had to hack around that using %f in textconv. I have also seen people write textconv programs without awareness that they might get binary data, and that blows up runtimes badly when you hit a NUL in an input buffer after an fgets() in C.\n\nI wish you luck in your adventure.\nRandall\n\n"},{"id":"551716","messageId":"AM0PR02MB4450445A9B2889A70CA49D5EB3B72@AM0PR02MB4450.eurprd02.prod.outlook.com","threadId":"66149","inReplyTo":"000601dd3a5b$3e4be8a0$bae3b9e0$@nexbridge.com","subject":"Re: AI Textconv filter misconfiguration on Windows leads to silent corruption of diff output (ongoing investigation)","fromName":"Skybuck Flying","fromEmail":"skybuck2000@hotmail.com","sentAt":"2026-09-02T00:27:13Z","receivedAt":"2026-09-02T00:27:15Z","isPatch":false,"body":"Hi,\n\nThanks for your reply.\n\nI think we can come to the conclusion there are no real text files, there is no real text standard.\n\nAll text files are ultimately binary files, some are ascii, some are ansi, some are unicode, etc.\n\nSome have codepage encodings, some have LF, some have CR, some have both, some have vice versa.\n\nSome have BOM some don't.\n\nBasically it is a GIGANTIC MESS.\n\nThis is probably the biggest flaw of git, assuming that there is such a thing is a text standard.\n\nPerhaps it's better to start treating everything as binary, and also creating, yet again a new true text standard ! LOL :)\n\nPDF, DOCS ? I once heard \"top demo coders\" use Microsoft Words to do their coding in. I am beginning to understand why that might be ! ;)\n\nPerhaps a new text format where there is no such thing as nil terminator and carriage returns and line feeds, but everything pre-fixed-lengths or so....\n\nThis would also solve the \"nil\" character frustration you shared, thanks for that !\n\nDownside for this new idea would be text length limited to what the number of length bits can hold. Which would be plenty for 32 or 64 bits.\n\nAlternatively, Skybuck's Universal Code or another flexible coding technique could be used as well.\n\nHowever, the alphabet itself is an encoding as well... Unicode feels a bit over done, with emotion smileys etc and other strange things, but it is a big world wide standard.\n\nPerhaps it could function as the encoding for the characters.\n\nThis would leave some binary format for text to be developed which would be suited for coding and editors.\n\nEditor could would become a bit more complex I suppose, to handle the prefix length fields and can no longer inject/delete characters, I am not sure how code editors work internally, maybe a doubled linked list of characters.\n\nPerhaps line numbers could be hard coded as well... or inferred/counted a bit more quicker... right now AI would have to count CR/LF characters which might make AI processing more expensive to find actual line numbers...\n\nI wonder...\n\nPlus some code could also be stored in \"line number segments/ranges\"... like lines 51 to 56... and perhaps line segments could be stored on disk directly, even randomly... and could be stitched together later sequentially for rendering purposes.\n\nHistorical changes might also be kept a bit more easy that way... like some kind of diff form... so I do see some potential for this...\n\nBye for now,\n  Skybuck."},{"id":"551717","messageId":"AM0PR02MB4450F00B19B3E0A1B357CC0EB3B72@AM0PR02MB4450.eurprd02.prod.outlook.com","threadId":"66149","inReplyTo":"AM0PR02MB4450445A9B2889A70CA49D5EB3B72@AM0PR02MB4450.eurprd02.prod.outlook.com","subject":"Re: AI Textconv filter misconfiguration on Windows leads to silent corruption of diff output (ongoing investigation)","fromName":"Skybuck Flying","fromEmail":"skybuck2000@hotmail.com","sentAt":"2026-09-02T01:35:46Z","receivedAt":"2026-09-02T01:35:50Z","isPatch":false,"body":"I have discussed the possibilities for a new text format with the AI based on my Universal Field Computer theory...\n\nI shall post what the AI came up with first, guided by me... first the copilot came up with all kinds of ridicilous things, so I switched to deepseek, then chatgpt, back to copilot some meta.ai too.\n\nMaybe I am not yet statisfied, but it's a start, consider this a draft for now, just a try out... maybe it's too complex, but it does have some advanced features... it also nicely integrates with unicode, but keeps the line seperator seperator.\n\nAfter this posting I will post my Universal Field Computer theory as discussed with the AI/copilot at the time. It was one of my most interesting discussions with an AI ever, I even youtubed about it, but the youtube account was banned by youtube.\n\nSo I think it's ok, to post that theory one more time somewhere on the internet, so people can actually RRRREADDD it... but it's very messy, basically an copilot html conversion saved as a text file. But it does contain some very interesting ideas for the future, even optimization for universal code and also graphs if I remember correctly, etc, even encoding the entire universe as a universal field.\n\nUNIVERSAL TEXT CODING SPECIFICATION (UTC)\nVersion 1.6 – Proposed Standard\nSeptember 2026\n\n\n1. INTRODUCTION\n\nThe Universal Text Coding (UTC) is a native textual representation for the Universal-\nField Computer (UFC) ecosystem. It encodes text as a sequence of self‑delimiting\nUniversal Fields (UFFields), each consisting of a Universal Integer (UFInt) TAG\nfollowed by a UFInt DATA value.\n\nUTC prioritises:\n\n- Deterministic and canonical representation.\n- Self‑delimiting field boundaries.\n- Structural clarity and auditability.\n- Uniform integration with Universal‑Field data models.\n- Safe and bounded decoding.\n\nUTC is not intended as a universal replacement for UTF‑8. It is the canonical native\ntext representation within UFC environments, with converters provided for inter‑\noperability with UTF‑8 and other conventional text encodings.\n\n\n2. TERMINOLOGY\n\nThe key words \"MUST\", \"MUST NOT\", \"REQUIRED\", \"SHALL\", \"SHALL NOT\", \"SHOULD\",\n\"SHOULD NOT\", \"MAY\" are to be interpreted as normative requirements.\n\nDefinitions:\n\n- UFInt: a self‑delimiting unsigned integer encoded using interleaved data and marker\n  bits.\n\n- UFField: a pair consisting of a UFInt TAG followed by a UFInt DATA.\n\n- Unicode scalar value: any Unicode code point from U+0000 through U+10FFFF,\n  excluding the surrogate range U+D800 through U+DFFF.\n\n- Raw UTC stream: a bitstream consisting exclusively of consecutive UFFields.\n\n- Bounded stream: a raw UTC stream whose exact logical bit length is known externally.\n\n- Terminated stream: a raw UTC stream terminated by an END_OF_TEXT field.\n\n- Frame: a byte‑oriented container wrapping a bounded raw UTC payload.\n\n- Logical bit length: the exact number of bits belonging to the UTC stream or payload,\n  excluding any physical storage padding.\n\n\n3. UFINT: CANONICAL UNIVERSAL INTEGER ENCODING\n\n3.1 Bit‑pair encoding\n\nA UFInt represents a non‑negative unsigned integer as a sequence of bit‑pairs:\n\n    (data_bit, marker_bit)\n\nThe marker bit indicates continuation:\n- 0 : another data bit follows.\n- 1 : this is the final data bit.\n\nThus every UFInt ends with a marker bit of 1.\n\n3.2 Bit order\n\nData bits are emitted most‑significant‑bit first.\n\nExample: integer 5 (binary 101) -> data bits 1,0,1 -> bit‑pairs: (1,0),(0,0),(1,1)\n-> UFInt: 100011.\n\n3.3 Canonical representation\n\nThe shortest possible binary representation SHALL be used. Leading zero data bits are\nforbidden except for the integer zero, which is encoded as the single bit‑pair (0,1)\n-> UFInt: 01.\n\nThus each integer has exactly one canonical UFInt representation.\n\n3.4 Canonical validation rule\n\nA UFInt whose first data bit is 0 is valid only if it consists of exactly the single\nbit‑pair 01 (representing zero). Any longer UFInt beginning with 00 is malformed and\nMUST be rejected by a strict decoder.\n\n3.5 Examples\n\n0 -> 01\n1 -> 11\n2 -> 1001\n3 -> 1011\n5 -> 100011\n65 -> 10000000000011\n\n\n4. BIT ORDER AND PHYSICAL STORAGE\n\n4.1 Logical bitstream\n\nUTC is defined as a logical bitstream. Fields may begin and end at arbitrary bit\npositions.\n\n4.2 Byte storage order\n\nWhen storing UTC bits in bytes, bit 7 of each byte is written first, followed by bit\n6, continuing through bit 0 (MSB‑first within each byte).\n\n4.3 Final byte padding\n\nIf the logical bitstream does not end on a byte boundary, the remaining bits of the\nfinal storage byte SHALL be set to zero. These padding bits are not part of the\nlogical stream. The exact logical bit length MUST be known when decoding a bounded\nstream. Padding bits MUST NOT be interpreted as UFInt data.\n\n\n5. UNIVERSAL FIELD STRUCTURE\n\nA UFField consists of exactly two consecutive UFInts:\n\n    [UFInt(TAG)] [UFInt(DATA)]\n\nThe decoder:\n1. reads one UFInt as TAG;\n2. reads one UFInt as DATA;\n3. treats the two UFInts as one complete field;\n4. then continues with the next field.\n\nNo separators exist between fields. Boundaries are implicit because both UFInts are\nself‑delimiting.\n\n\n6. UTC CORE FIELD TYPES\n\nVersion 1.6 defines the following core field types.\n\n+-------------------+--------+-------------------+---------------------------------+\n| Field Type        | TAG    | DATA              | Meaning                         |\n+-------------------+--------+-------------------+---------------------------------+\n| END_OF_TEXT       | 0      | 0                 | Explicit stream terminator      |\n| CHARACTER         | 1      | Unicode scalar    | One Unicode code point          |\n+-------------------+--------+-------------------+---------------------------------+\n| LINE_SEPARATOR    | 2      | 0                 | Structural line break           |\n+-------------------+--------+-------------------+---------------------------------+\n\nEND_OF_TEXT is encoded as UFInt(0) + UFInt(0) -> 01 01 -> 0101.\n\nCHARACTER field: TAG=1, DATA is a Unicode scalar value (0x0000..0x10FFFF, excluding\nsurrogates). A CHARACTER field represents exactly one Unicode scalar value; it does\nnot necessarily represent one grapheme cluster.\n\nLINE_SEPARATOR: TAG=2, DATA=0. Encoded as UFInt(2)+UFInt(0) -> 1001 01 -> 100101.\n\n\n7. TAG ALLOCATION AND EXTENSIBILITY\n\nTAG ranges for UTC Version 1.x:\n\n- 0: END_OF_TEXT\n- 1: CHARACTER\n- 2: LINE_SEPARATOR\n- 3–31: reserved for future core structural fields\n- 32–255: available for application or profile extensions\n- >255: reserved for future specification versions\n\nA strict decoder MUST reject an unknown TAG. A permissive decoder MAY preserve or\nskip unknown fields only when explicitly configured to do so; such permissive mode\nmust not be the default.\n\n\n8. NEWLINE CONVERSION\n\nUTC distinguishes structural line breaks from literal Unicode characters.\n\nThree import policies are defined:\n\n8.1 CANONICAL (default)\n\nThe following line‑break forms are converted to exactly one LINE_SEPARATOR field:\nLF, CR, CRLF, NEL, Unicode LINE SEPARATOR (U+2028), and PARAGRAPH SEPARATOR (U+2029).\nCRLF is recognised atomically and does not produce two separators.\n\n8.2 LITERAL\n\nNo automatic conversion occurs; every code point is encoded as a CHARACTER field.\n\n8.3 PRESERVE\n\nThe original line‑break form may be preserved via external metadata or a dedicated\nprofile; this is outside the core UTC specification.\n\n\n9. UNICODE NORMALISATION\n\nUTC does not perform automatic normalisation. Converters MAY support normalisation\nforms: NONE (default), NFC, NFD, NFKC, NFKD. Normalisation MUST be explicit and\ndocumented; it is not performed by a raw UTC decoder.\n\n\n10. RAW UTC STREAM PROFILES\n\n10.1 Bounded stream\n\nA bounded stream has an externally known logical bit length. The decoder parses\nUFFields until that bit length is exhausted. END_OF_TEXT is forbidden.\n\n10.2 Terminated stream\n\nA terminated stream ends with exactly one END_OF_TEXT field (TAG=0,DATA=0). The\nfield must occur exactly once and be the last logical field. Physical padding after\nit is ignored.\n\n\n11. OPTIONAL UTC FRAME CONTAINER\n\nA frame is a byte‑oriented wrapper for bounded UTC payloads. It is intended for\nstorage, streaming, random access, and corruption recovery.\n\n11.1 Frame layout (big‑endian)\n\n+-----------------------------------------------------------------+\n| SYNC (32 bits)                  | 0x55AA55AA                     |\n+-----------------------------------------------------------------+\n| VERSION (8 bits)                | 0x01                           |\n+-----------------------------------------------------------------+\n| FLAGS (8 bits)                  | bit0: CRC‑32C present          |\n|                                 | bits1‑7: reserved (zero)      |\n+-----------------------------------------------------------------+\n| PAYLOAD_BIT_LENGTH (32 bits)    | exact logical bits of payload  |\n+-----------------------------------------------------------------+\n| PAYLOAD                         | raw bounded UTC stream         |\n+-----------------------------------------------------------------+\n| optional CRC‑32C (32 bits)      | if FLAGS bit0 = 1              |\n+-----------------------------------------------------------------+\n\nSYNC is the constant 0x55AA55AA. VERSION is 1. Reserved FLAGS bits MUST be zero.\n\n11.2 PAYLOAD\n\nPAYLOAD_BIT_LENGTH specifies the exact logical bit count. The physical payload\nbytes = ceil(PAYLOAD_BIT_LENGTH/8). Unused bits in the final payload byte MUST be\nzero and are not part of the logical payload. The payload must be a valid bounded\nUTC stream and MUST NOT contain END_OF_TEXT.\n\n11.3 CRC‑32C\n\nIf FLAGS bit0 = 1, a CRC‑32C value is appended as 4 bytes in big‑endian order.\nThe CRC covers the physical payload bytes (including any zero padding in the final\nbyte) but excludes SYNC, VERSION, FLAGS, PAYLOAD_BIT_LENGTH, and the CRC itself.\n\nCRC‑32C uses the Castagnoli polynomial 0x1EDC6F41 with initial value 0xFFFFFFFF and\nfinal XOR 0xFFFFFFFF.\n\nTest vector: for the 9‑byte ASCII string \"123456789\", the CRC‑32C value is 0xE3069283.\n\n11.4 Frame padding\n\nNo arbitrary padding bytes are permitted between frames. The next frame begins\nimmediately after the payload (or CRC).\n\n\n12. FRAME SYNCHRONISATION AND RECOVERY\n\nA candidate frame is valid only after the following checks succeed:\n- SYNC matches 0x55AA55AA.\n- VERSION is supported.\n- Reserved FLAGS bits are zero.\n- PAYLOAD_BIT_LENGTH does not exceed configured limits.\n- Enough data exists for the full payload.\n- Final payload padding bits are zero.\n- CRC‑32C matches, if present.\n- The payload is syntactically valid UTC.\n\nA recovery‑capable decoder MAY search for the next SYNC after a failure. It MUST\nenforce configurable limits on bytes scanned and consecutive failed attempts to\navoid resource exhaustion.\n\n\n13. ERROR HANDLING AND RESOURCE LIMITS\n\n13.1 Malformed UFInt\n\nA UFInt is malformed if it lacks a final marker, exceeds configured limits, or\ncontains a non‑canonical leading zero. The decoder MUST report the bit offset and\nfield index, and in strict mode MUST stop decoding the current raw stream.\n\n13.2 Invalid CHARACTER DATA\n\nDATA outside the valid Unicode scalar range (including surrogates) is invalid and\nMUST be rejected. A decoder must not reinterpret invalid data as valid.\n\n13.3 Invalid LINE_SEPARATOR DATA\n\nFor TAG=2, only DATA=0 is valid. Any other DATA value is invalid.\n\n13.4 END_OF_TEXT errors\n\nEND_OF_TEXT is forbidden in bounded streams and must be the final field in terminated\nstreams. Extra fields after END_OF_TEXT are invalid.\n\n13.5 Unknown TAG\n\nStrict decoders reject unknown TAGs. Permissive mode is only allowed when explicitly\nenabled.\n\n13.6 CRC failure\n\nA CRC mismatch indicates corruption; the frame is invalid. Recovery may search for\nthe next SYNC.\n\n13.7 Resource limits (normative)\n\nImplementations MUST enforce configurable resource limits. The default limits for\nVersion 1.6 are:\n\n- TAG UFInt: 8 significant data bits (TAG <= 255).\n- CHARACTER DATA: 21 significant data bits (max Unicode scalar).\n- LINE_SEPARATOR DATA: 1 significant data bit (must be 0).\n- Other/core control UFInts: appropriate to their field.\n- Extension UFInts: 1024 significant data bits (unless configured otherwise).\n- Maximum fields per stream/frame: implementation‑defined (configurable).\n- Maximum bytes scanned during recovery: implementation‑defined (configurable).\n\nA decoder MUST enforce these limits while decoding and reject a UFInt as soon as the\napplicable limit is exceeded, before allocating resources based on the full value.\n\n\n14. FRAMING IMPLEMENTATION RECOMMENDATIONS\n\nFramed mode is RECOMMENDED for:\n- network transport,\n- unreliable media,\n- streaming environments requiring corruption recovery,\n- applications needing random access or independently verifiable payload segments.\n\nCRC‑32C SHOULD be enabled unless performance constraints justify its omission.\n\nThese recommendations are non‑normative; implementations may choose framing or raw\nstreams according to their context.\n\n\n15. CONFORMANCE REQUIREMENTS\n\nA conforming UTC implementation MUST correctly process:\n- canonical UFInt encoding and reject non‑canonical forms in strict mode.\n- UFField parsing.\n- all core field types.\n- bounded streams (with exact bit length).\n- terminated streams (with END_OF_TEXT).\n- final‑byte zero padding handling.\n- Unicode scalar validation.\n\nA conforming frame implementation MUST additionally support:\n- SYNC validation.\n- VERSION validation.\n- FLAGS validation.\n- PAYLOAD_BIT_LENGTH.\n- zero padding validation.\n- CRC‑32C verification when present.\n\n\n16. CONFORMANCE TEST SUITE\n\nThe UTC specification SHALL be accompanied by an official conformance test suite.\nThe suite MUST include both positive and negative tests covering:\n\nPositive:\n- All core field encodings.\n- ASCII, BMP, non‑BMP, and combining character sequences.\n- Line breaks under CANONICAL, LITERAL, and PRESERVE policies.\n- Terminated streams.\n- Bounded streams with correct bit length.\n- Framed streams with valid CRC.\n- Padding cases.\n\nNegative:\n- Non‑canonical UFInts (leading zero).\n- Incomplete UFInts.\n- Surrogate code points.\n- Code points > U+10FFFF.\n- LINE_SEPARATOR with DATA != 0.\n- END_OF_TEXT in bounded stream.\n- Fields after END_OF_TEXT.\n- Unknown TAG in strict mode.\n- Invalid FLAGS bits.\n- CRC mismatch.\n- Incorrect payload length.\n\nEach test case MUST specify:\n- input bitstream or physical bytes,\n- expected outcome (ACCEPT/REJECT),\n- error category if REJECT,\n- logical bit length where applicable.\n\nThe suite SHALL include the canonical CRC‑32C test vector `\"123456789\" -> E3069283`.\n\n\n17. DEBUG AND INSPECTION REPRESENTATION\n\nFor human inspection, implementations MAY use the format:\n\n    UF:TAG=<decimal> DATA=<hex> bits=<binary>\n\nExamples:\n    UF:TAG=1 DATA=0x41 bits=1110000000000011\n    UF:TAG=2 DATA=0x0 bits=100101\n    UF:TAG=0 DATA=0x0 bits=0101\n\n\n18. TEST VECTORS\n\n18.1 Integer zero\nUFInt: 01\n\n18.2 Integer one\nUFInt: 11\n\n18.3 Integer two\nUFInt: 1001\n\n18.4 Invalid non‑canonical one\n0011 -> MUST be rejected (forbidden leading zero)\n\n18.5 CHARACTER 'A'\nTAG=1, DATA=65\nTAG bits: 11\nDATA bits: 10000000000011\nField: 1110000000000011 (16 bits)\nStorage: E0 03\n\n18.6 LINE_SEPARATOR\nTAG=2, DATA=0\nTAG: 1001\nDATA: 01\nField: 100101 (6 bits)\n\n18.7 Empty terminated stream\nFields: END_OF_TEXT\nBits: 0101\nStorage: 01010000 -> 0x50\n\n18.8 Text \"A\\nB\" (CANONICAL import)\nFields: CHAR 'A', LINE_SEPARATOR, CHAR 'B'\nBitstream: 1110000000000011 100101 1110000000001001\nConcatenated: 1110000000000011100101111000000000001001\nLogical length: 40 bits\nPhysical hex (big‑endian, padded to bytes): E0 03 97 80 09\n\n\n19. DESIGN PRINCIPLES\n\n- Everything textual is represented through universal fields.\n- Every integer has one canonical representation.\n- Field boundaries are self‑delimiting.\n- Structural information is explicit.\n- Logical representation is separated from physical storage.\n- Raw UTC is separated from optional framing.\n- Legacy conventions are handled at conversion boundaries.\n- Auditability and determinism take priority over storage efficiency.\n\n\n20. CONCLUSION\n\nUTC Version 1.6 consolidates the core specification with explicit resource limits,\nclear recovery guidelines, a defined CRC‑32C test vector, and a plan for a complete\nconformance test suite. It provides a stable, implementable foundation for native\ntextual representation within the Universal‑Field Computer ecosystem, while leaving\nroom for future extensions through separate profiles without altering the core\nsemantics.\n\n--- End of Specification ---\n\nBye for now,\n  Skybuck."},{"id":"551748","messageId":"CALnO6CAhXeADt+pZbR4=RaksmrXLtwtCXhnxMHHtAy3spuhptg@mail.gmail.com","threadId":"66149","inReplyTo":"000601dd3a5b$3e4be8a0$bae3b9e0$@nexbridge.com","subject":"Re: AI Textconv filter misconfiguration on Windows leads to silent corruption of diff output (ongoing investigation)","fromName":"D. Ben Knoble","fromEmail":"ben.knoble@gmail.com","sentAt":"2026-09-02T12:14:19Z","receivedAt":"2026-09-02T12:14:32Z","isPatch":false,"body":"On Tue, Sep 1, 2026 at 5:59 PM <rsbecker@nexbridge.com> wrote:\n>\n> On September 1, 2026 4:14 PM, Skybuck Flying wrote:\n> >MORE GOD DAMN PROBLEMS WITH GIT AND CR/LF FILTERS.\n> >\n> >I DOWNLOADED/GIT CLONED:\n> >\n> >https://github.com/openai/openai-openapi/tree/main\n> >\n> >I NOTICED:\n> >\n> >https://github.com/openai/openai-openapi/tree/main/assets\n> >\n> >WAS CORRUPTED.\n> >\n> >(CORRECT DOWNLOAD METHOD USES TO PROVE FILE IS INTACT ON SERVER):\n> >\n> >curl -L --output \"K:\\Delphi\\Specifications\\OpenAI API\\github version 3.1.0 (1\n> >september 2026)\\assets\\openai-api-referencev2.png\"\n> >https://raw.githubusercontent.com/openai/openai-\n> >openapi/master/assets/openai-api-reference.png\n> >\n> >GOOD THING I INSPECTED IT JUST OUT OF CURIOSITY.\n> >\n> >I IMMEDIATELY EXPECTED GIT FILTER TO BE THE CAUSE.\n> >\n> >DIAGNOSIS COMMANDS.\n> >\n> >\"\n> >Microsoft Windows [Version 10.0.22631.6199]\n> >(c) Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved.\n> >\n> >C:\\Users\\skybu>git config --global core.autocrlf false\n> >\n> >C:\\Users\\skybu>git config --system core.autocrlf false\n> >\n> >C:\\Users\\skybu>git config --local core.autocrlf\n> >fatal: --local can only be used inside a git repository\n> >\n> >C:\\Users\\skybu>git config --global --get-regexp filter\n> >\n> >C:\\Users\\skybu>git config --local --get-regexp filter\n> >fatal: --local can only be used inside a git repository\n> >\n> >C:\\Users\\skybu>git check-attr -a openai-api-reference.png\n> >fatal: not a git repository (or any of the parent directories): .git\n> >\n> >C:\\Users\\skybu>type .gitattributes\n> >* text diff=lfclean\n> >C:\\Users\\skybu>git config --global --list core.autocrlf=false core.eol=crlf\n> >core.sshcommand=C:/Windows/System32/OpenSSH/ssh.exe\n> >core.attributesfile=C:\\Users\\skybu\\.gitattributes\n> >user.email=skybuck2000@hotmail.com\n> >user.name=Skybuck Flying\n> >user.signingkey=I:\\Informatie\\Van mezelf\\SSH Keys\\PrivateKey\\GitSigningKey\n> >gui.recentrepo=V:/FuckingWhore/vite-wallet\n> >cinnabar.version-check=1743733941\n> >credential.http://localhost:3000.provider=generic\n> >includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0001/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0001-v2\n> >includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0002/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0002-v2\n> >includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0003/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0003-v2\n> >includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0004/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0004-v2\n> >includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0005/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0005-v2\n> >includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0006/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0006-v2\n> >includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0007/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0007-v2\n> >includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0008/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0008-v2\n> >includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0009/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0009-v2\n> >includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0010/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0010-v2\n> >includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0011/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0011-v2\n> >includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0012/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0012-v2\n> >includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0013/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0013-v2\n> >includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0014/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0014-v2\n> >includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0015/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0015-v2\n> >includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0016/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0016-v2\n> >includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0017/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0017-v2\n> >includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0018/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0018-v2\n> >includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0019/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0019-v2\n> >includeif.gitdir:V:/AI0020/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-ai0020-v2\n> >includeif.gitdir:V:/AIMain/.path=~/.gitconfigs/.gitconfig-aimain-v2\n> >merge.tool=meld\n> >mergetool.prompt=false\n> >mergetool.keepbackup=false\n> >gpg.format=ssh\n> >commit.gpgsign=true\n> >log.showsignature=true\n> >gpg.ssh.allowedsignersfile=I:/Informatie/Van mezelf/SSH\n> >Keys/GitAllowedSigners/GitAllowedSigners.txt\n> >diff.lfclean.textconv=sed -e s/\\\\r//\n> >diff.lfclean.binary=false\n> >\n> >C:\\Users\\skybu>git check-attr --all -- openai-api-reference.png\n> >fatal: not a git repository (or any of the parent directories): .git\n> >\n> >C:\\Users\\skybu>\n> >\"\n> >\n> >HYPOTHESIS BY CO-PILOT AND POSSIBLE FIX:\n> >\n> >The **smoking gun is now visible**: your global config + your global attributes file\n> >**are applying a custom diff filter (`lfclean`) to *all files*** — including PNGs.\n> >That is exactly why your Git‑downloaded PNG is corrupted while the curl version is\n> >intact.\n> >\n[snip]\n>\n> Just some musings from my own frustration in this area.\n>\n> Having gone through some similar things, I would ignore CoPilot. There are other words I would use as well but they are not for polite company.\n>\n> Set autocrlf=input not false. Also it is a good idea to set ignorecase=true and filemode=false on Windows.\n>\n> Git tends to give preferential treatment to text files, only looking at the first hunk (whatever that might be) looking for non-text characters. CR is text, so a file containing those near the front will probably be consider text unless explicitly marked as binary. If you are sure you have binary files, declare them. Do not assume git will always get it right - although .EXE, .ZIP, .JPG, and .PNG are pretty much always binary.\n\nYeah, I suspect the \"* text\" is more likely the culprit than \"*\ndiff=lfclean\": I don't think Git runs diff-filters on blobs to produce\nthe checked out versions. That is, I don't think anyone is doing the\nequivalent o\n\n    <$input sed -e s/\\\\r// >$output\n\nwhere input is the PNG blob and output is the corrupted filename.\n(CoPilot seems confidently wrong as usual about this.)\n\nInstead, we can check \"git help attributes\" to see what happens.\n\n1.  The text attribute enables some conversion of line endings: always\nLF in the index, and possibly converted in the working tree.\n\n          This attribute marks the path as a text file, which enables\n           end-of-line conversion: When a matching file is added to the index,\n           the file’s line endings are normalized to LF in the index.\n           Conversely, when the file is copied from the index to the working\n           directory, its line endings may be converted from LF to CRLF\n           depending on the eol attribute, the Git config, and the platform\n           (see explanation of eol below).\n\n2. The eol attribute when unspecified uses core.autocrlf or core.eol\nconfig; when _those_ are unspecified, it's crlf on Windows (converting\nLF to CRLF).\n\n               If the eol attribute is unspecified for a file, its line endings\n               in the working directory are determined by the core.autocrlf or\n               core.eol configuration variable (see the definitions of those\n               options in git-config(1)). If text is set but neither of those\n               variables is, the default is eol=crlf on Windows and eol=lf on\n               all other platforms.\n\nSo as Randall says, don't tell Git files are text if they aren't :)\nUsing \"* text=auto\" might be safer (allowing Git to decide whether a\nfile is text) if you need line ending normalization.\n\n-- \nD. Ben Knoble\n"},{"id":"551804","messageId":"AM0PR02MB4450D5755BA65E3C2CA324C0B3B72@AM0PR02MB4450.eurprd02.prod.outlook.com","threadId":"66149","inReplyTo":"CALnO6CAhXeADt+pZbR4=RaksmrXLtwtCXhnxMHHtAy3spuhptg@mail.gmail.com","subject":"Re: AI Textconv filter misconfiguration on Windows leads to silent corruption of diff output (ongoing investigation)","fromName":"Skybuck Flying","fromEmail":"skybuck2000@hotmail.com","sentAt":"2026-09-02T19:43:21Z","receivedAt":"2026-09-02T19:43:37Z","isPatch":false,"body":"\"\nSo as Randall says, don't tell Git files are text if they aren't :)\nUsing \"* text=auto\" might be safer (allowing Git to decide whether a\nfile is text) if you need line ending normalization.\n\"\n\nYeah, same conclusion as AI.\n\nBut the real question is:\n\n1. How to do that ?\n\n2. Is it truely safe ? Or will it lead to further problems.\n\n3. I don't have time to read obscure old git manuals from the 70's about * and all kinds of strange rules.\n\n^ Thus I do believe I have a slight point here, the command line is ancient enough already, apperently it requires some .gitattribute file and set blabla * text * png * bmp.\n\nThe whole thing does not make much sense to me, the syntax don't make much sense.\n\n* is in ms-dos everything... so using this in this way in git is bizar/strange/alien/non-intuitive/can't wrap my head around, doesn't make any sense... etc ?! Get the vibe ?\n\nAlso my 4th though is:\n\n4. Do I then have to do this for every possible binary file and tell git which files are binary ? The whole thing kinda stinks... but maybe there is no other solution.\n\nFor now I have \"better\" or \"other\" things to do then keep experimenting with this dangerous stuff for something as silly as CR LF in text files.\n\nFor now the AI advised me to delete .gitattributes and I did just that and will continue using a more or less default installation from GIT to prevent any corruption which would be horrible.\n\nYesterday I wrote two programs with AI:\n\n1. One to scan 68 repositories which were posted online to make sure they were not corrupted, thankfully non of them was corrupted.\n\n2. A git repo finder/scanner which scans my folders for .git folders from a certain date. Thankfully Co-Pilot still remembered at what date I enabled this flawed git filter.\n\nSo finding those repos was kinda easy. I found about 3 to 4 or something so far. At least one of them had corrupted PNGs as well. (Doc folders)\n\nTwo of them I re-cloned just in case...\n\nSo far I have been kinda lucky to find this issue with 2 months and have had not too much git cloning activity... it could have turned into a much bigger disaster if text files were corrupted instead of binary files.\n\nBinary files kinda rare in git repos and with a bit of luck they don't have CR/LF in them... Text files on the other hand are everywhere in git... text file corrupted would have been a major problem.\n\nFor me a simpler solution where git has some kind of \"list\" of files, and then enable/disable...\n\nMaybe some list which tells git if it's binary or not.\n\nSomething simple like:\n\nPNG binary\nBMP binary\nTXT text\nPAS text\nDPR text\nJPG binary\n\nThat would make more sense to me, without the * etc... why is the * asterix necessary at all ?\n\nHowever I would demand a pre-made list... because this is kinda nuts to do this yourself.\n\nPlus, this is still not ideal.\n\nWhat if an application saves files in a known extension from this list, it's supposed to be binary... but will be mistreated as text...\n\nI guess this is the risk with git after all or maybe not, maybe you have a point with auto detection.\n\nIt would be amazing if git detects a *.pas as being binary... because some tool happens to use that as it's data files.\n\nSo for now, I would agree with you auto detection maybe best, but why does this not solve the diff problem with ^M everywhere ? Hmmm.\n\nBye for now,\n  Skybuck."}]}